Quote:
Originally Posted by horseofcourse
It's all good. Lee didn't win a ring in 2009 with the Phils, but he was certainly by far the best pitcher that post season and it's not even debatable. Just because he didn't win a "ring" that year doesn't diminish in my mind what he did. I still say that right now, a Giants fan can certainly argue that they currently have the best rotation in the NL even with the Phils signing of Lee. The old man of the Giants 4 is Sanchez at 28. 3 of the Phillies 4 are all over 30.
|
Halladay and Let Timmy Smoke are a wash
Lee > Cain ( I think Cain is way better than Sanchez)
Hamels & Oswalt > Sanchez and Bumgardner (sp?)
but Giants have a great rotation, and any of those guys can certainly shut down any team on any night... proven in the playoffs.
As for what rotation would be better in 2018? Yeah I'll go with Giants.