Matt Barkley threw for about 400 more yards than Andrew Luck, threw for 39 TD's and only 7 INT's while Luck threw 35 TD's with 9 INT's. Not to mention his team won 10 games and a division with essentially no incentive to because they couldn't play in any bowls or conference championship games.
I'm not saying he should win the thing, but he belongs in NY. His case is as good if not better than Luck's based on what they did on the field.
|