Quote:
|
Originally Posted by RolloTomasi
And what he doesn't know is Lava Man personally. And what else he doesn't know is what sort of response the horse will have to stem cell therapy, very much in the fledgling stages. I understand he has a lot experience training racehorses, but he's reading the same news reports us Googlers are, and last time I checked, holding a valid trainer's license doesn't concurrently endow you with the skill or knowledge of veterinary medicine, never mind make you well-versed in stem cell therapy.
I don't know if anyone in this thread who supports this return to training could be labeled "excited". However, the detractors who try to make this more or less dime-a-dozen comeback story some sort of hot button issue by flame-throwing terms like "liar" and "dead horse" could possibly be considered to have their respective panties in a bunch.
I think there is more vanity driving the effort on this board to denounce this move, rather than that which prods the horse's connections along.
Embarrassment or humilation for the game...or for Old Friends (who have committed a lot of publicity--within the racing world anyways--to his retirement there)?
And while we're looking at the bigger picture here, holding his connections accountable for how this singular move might affect "the game", what sort of upside would the horse represent for the sport should he make it back and show ANY kind of winning form? What sort of boost would that be to proponents of stem cell therapy specifically and equine injury research in general?
|
Amazing that my qualifications are now the topic. How exactly do you know what i know? I do know that I know quite a bit about the practical application of Stem Cell therapy in equines due to the fact I have had horses in my care receive the treatment (the first one was years ago by the way-it aint that new), the fact that a close friend who happens to be a surgeon worked extensively on Stemcell research and has been one of its biggest proponents (and yeah maybe just maybe we have had a conversation about this and similar scenarios), and I am pretty sure that I know far more from a practical standpoint about veteranarian medicine than anyone here. The vain detractors like me are simply pointing out the issue is far more complicated than it seems and the therapy used is not only not groundbreaking or new it has been used on hundreds/thousands of other horses with varying levels of sucess. One thing that the Dr did tell me is how much more effective stem cell therapy works in younger horses. And 9 isnt younger. But my main point was that the odds of him coming back and competing at a high level are so remote that when weighed against the possibility of something really negative happening it just isnt worth it.