Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   The Power of Compounding (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75236)

moses 02-26-2026 05:46 PM

The Power of Compounding
 
So it’s been a while. I hope everyone is doing well.

I’ve recently become intrigued with the idea of taking a small initial bet ($5, 10, 20…nothing major) and seeing how many consecutive show bets I can hit while rolling the winnings forward each bet.

With an average payout of $2.50 to show, it would take 25 consecutive winning wagers to hit $5,000. I suspect if I get on a streak that I’ll chicken out before I hit the $5,000 mark or entirely lose discipline and start dipping into those funds for other wagers.

But that said, how dumb is this idea? Has anyone attempted it? After spending entirely too much money last year chasing Pick 5 payouts and essentially breaking even, I’m wondering if this might actually be easier. It seems that way but then again, maybe my average payout is optimistic or maybe my self confidence in being able to do it 25 times in a row is misplaced. Of course, all it takes is one miss and I’m back to the starting line.

Anyway, sound off. I’d love some feedback.

jms62 02-27-2026 06:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moses (Post 1185896)
So it’s been a while. I hope everyone is doing well.

I’ve recently become intrigued with the idea of taking a small initial bet ($5, 10, 20…nothing major) and seeing how many consecutive show bets I can hit while rolling the winnings forward each bet.

With an average payout of $2.50 to show, it would take 25 consecutive winning wagers to hit $5,000. I suspect if I get on a streak that I’ll chicken out before I hit the $5,000 mark or entirely lose discipline and start dipping into those funds for other wagers.

But that said, how dumb is this idea? Has anyone attempted it? After spending entirely too much money last year chasing Pick 5 payouts and essentially breaking even, I’m wondering if this might actually be easier. It seems that way but then again, maybe my average payout is optimistic or maybe my self confidence in being able to do it 25 times in a row is misplaced. Of course, all it takes is one miss and I’m back to the starting line.

Anyway, sound off. I’d love some feedback.

First Problem is

That is an AVERAGE payout which includes horses paying $20+ to show and 2.50 average implies an 80% win rate. It is highly unlikely ANY of us would include those $20+ horses while trying to maintain a streak trying to get to 25 in a row.

Second Problem is

even at 80% or .80 Win rate that is .80^25 which is multiplying .80 by itself 25 times. This gives us .00377 or 0.37% chance of completing the streak. This is 272-1 which is quite Good to get $5000 HOWEVER the First Problem comes into play as you are not going to get close to that AVERAGE. Also do we EVER really know that a horse has an 80% chance to show given each race has its own dynamics and perils.

3rd Problem

Your BETS will be increasing and that will be LOWERING and in some tracks SUBSTANTIALLY what the Show horse pays so again we are getting farther away from that 2.50 Average.

25 in a row at $2.50 Average IMO not doable in the Number of years I have left.

knickslions2 02-27-2026 11:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moses (Post 1185896)
So it’s been a while. I hope everyone is doing well.

I’ve recently become intrigued with the idea of taking a small initial bet ($5, 10, 20…nothing major) and seeing how many consecutive show bets I can hit while rolling the winnings forward each bet.

With an average payout of $2.50 to show, it would take 25 consecutive winning wagers to hit $5,000. I suspect if I get on a streak that I’ll chicken out before I hit the $5,000 mark or entirely lose discipline and start dipping into those funds for other wagers.

But that said, how dumb is this idea? Has anyone attempted it? After spending entirely too much money last year chasing Pick 5 payouts and essentially breaking even, I’m wondering if this might actually be easier. It seems that way but then again, maybe my average payout is optimistic or maybe my self confidence in being able to do it 25 times in a row is misplaced. Of course, all it takes is one miss and I’m back to the starting line.

Anyway, sound off. I’d love some feedback.

Our group does show parlays all the time. We start $5 per person and pass ticket around after each race. If we get it up to a few hundred we cash out are start over. 25 in a row is crazy and can’t see getting even close to it. It’s fun side bet. We definitely shoot for some prices . Good luck

moses 02-27-2026 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jms62 (Post 1185898)
First Problem is

That is an AVERAGE payout which includes horses paying $20+ to show and 2.50 average implies an 80% win rate. It is highly unlikely ANY of us would include those $20+ horses while trying to maintain a streak trying to get to 25 in a row.

Second Problem is

even at 80% or .80 Win rate that is .80^25 which is multiplying .80 by itself 25 times. This gives us .00377 or 0.37% chance of completing the streak. This is 272-1 which is quite Good to get $5000 HOWEVER the First Problem comes into play as you are not going to get close to that AVERAGE. Also do we EVER really know that a horse has an 80% chance to show given each race has its own dynamics and perils.

3rd Problem

Your BETS will be increasing and that will be LOWERING and in some tracks SUBSTANTIALLY what the Show horse pays so again we are getting farther away from that 2.50 Average.

25 in a row at $2.50 Average IMO not doable in the Number of years I have left.

Sorry, I was saying my goal would averaging $2.50. I think the actual show payout average is higher than that. That said, all your points remain and are well taken.

I still think I’ll give it a try for the fun of it.

moses 02-27-2026 02:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by knickslions2 (Post 1185899)
Our group does show parlays all the time. We start $5 per person and pass ticket around after each race. If we get it up to a few hundred we cash out are start over. 25 in a row is crazy and can’t see getting even close to it. It’s fun side bet. We definitely shoot for some prices . Good luck

What’s the highest you’ve ever gotten it up to?

I was thinking of trying to do this over the course of the next 10 weeks, only betting on Saturdays and Sunday’s, maybe 1-2 bets per day.

casp0555 02-27-2026 04:15 PM

I would be happy with getting five in a row :o:wf

ninetoone 02-28-2026 08:44 AM

I'm not this patient. If I was looking to get to 5K, I'd be more inclined to put 5K on an even money shot...LOL

moses 02-28-2026 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ninetoone (Post 1185917)
I'm not this patient. If I was looking to get to 5K, I'd be more inclined to put 5K on an even money shot...LOL

lol — I’m not this patient either and not disciplined enough.

I’m going to start with $5 so it’s going to take longer. First bet — Noble Confessor in Race 1 at Gulfstream. Let’s see if I can at least hit 1 in a row.

moses 02-28-2026 11:38 AM

Haha.

Ok. Might be a little tougher than I anticipated.

fantini33 03-01-2026 11:31 AM

There is a reason why "Showvivor" contests that have literally hundreds of good handicappers playing, where you only need to make a single play per card, rarely make it beyond 2 weeks. I've toyed with the idea in big live money contests, where you could potentially turn $10000 into just under 70k with a run of five at $3 per payout. On big race days (BC, Derby, Travers, etc) getting 3 beans for a 2 to 1 shot isnt impossible. I mythically tried it a few times and not once was successful.

If you are playing pick 5's all year and are breaking even you are probably swimming in the right pool. IMO.

moses 03-01-2026 06:44 PM

My first two bets whiffed. I came back today with a $10 show bet on Class President in the Rebel. Of course he won and paid $19.

But I’ll take the $25.00.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:16 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.