Yeah -- the flaw is with the voter.
Some of them might make the Cotillion out to be like a definitive head-to-head match-up. They will also award My Miss Aurelia a lot of extra credit for her result in the BC Distaff with no real regard for trip.
The great performances by Questing at Saratoga might be unrated by voters not able to discern the quality of the performance.
This one was a crazy year for the 3yo filly eclipse:
http://test.drf.com/eclipse/2005/pps/3f.pdf
If you get a chance this week, see if the Le Prince race can be discovered and posted.