Quote:
Originally Posted by Dahoss
I don't know how to change it, but not giving the most deserving horse an award he deserves isn't the way.
|
Let me ask you this - how much of a curve do you grade on when grading a mare against an older male?
I think if you're ultimately grading these horses on accomplishments, quality of performance and difficulty of campaign... Blame will have a slight but very clear edge over Zenyatta. You're grading an older male against a mare though .. so it really boils down to what kind of a curve you're grading on - or if you're applying the curve in your grading at all.
No one was louder than I was about how soft Zenyatta's campaign has been - and how soft her Grade 1 wins have been - but she is a mare. I think that fact is getting lost on a few of the smarter people around here. Just as the fact that Rachel Alexandra was a 3-year-old filly last year .. and Zenyatta was a mare .. seemed to get lost on a lot of people last year.
The fact that RA was a 3yo filly - actually should have made her a unanimous winner - taking every single vote in 2009 IMO.
If you're not going to apply a curve - a 2-year-old will never win this award. A 3-year-old filly will almost never win this award. And a mare will almost never win this award.