View Single Post
  #3  
Old 06-26-2010, 03:21 PM
Cannon Shell's Avatar
Cannon Shell Cannon Shell is offline
Sha Tin
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 20,855
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind View Post
The problem with this argument, and you know this, is that this is a very finite and specific meet/situation, and moving the money to the second meet doesn't matter. In fact, what they are doing is saving money so there can be a second meet, or at least one that isn't skeletal. Having more money for that meet, but failing to give away the average in this one, doesn't change things.

The other thing your argument ignores is that you parse the money out in the manner you suggest, which obviously I understand and agree in theory with what you are saying, when your results will allow you to increase purses later. Well, while the handle numbers have been phenomenally good, and surely way better than I expected, they still don't justify these purse levels, even with the subsidy, so how exactly can that translate into raising purses later in this 50 day session....or at least enough to meet the announced average?

Once again, so that it is clear, this Monmouth meeting has been a great success from a fan's perspective, and that is a great thing. Nobody can, or should, argue with that. However, that doesn't preclude having some realistic discussions about other facets of the plan. In fact, this should be especially important in this example given how many people claim this is a blueprint for a direction racing could, should, or must be not only exploring but perhaps heading towards. Looking at all parts, and honestly seeing how well they work, is the only way to reach intelligent and successful conclusions.
Very true yet we are using assumptions for numbers which makes it tough to accurately determine. In this case much of the money is "found" money unlike any other meet and I have no idea what they are required to do with it.

No one is arguing that the current purse structure is sustainable. I dont think that was really part of the discussion that I was involved with. But the idea that they dont/didnt intend to distribute the 50 million just seems like conjecture.

I dont really think that we will be able to discuss the success or relative success of this entire experiment accurately until it is over and we have the numbers to examine. In my mind simply doing what Monmouth is doing without any additional source of purse money isnt really going to change the direction of anything. Hell Calder has already tried this a few years ago with mixed results. What we all want to know is how to quantify the increased field size and quality of racing and the subsequent gain in handle into a number where the purse structure needed can be accurately determined. In otherwords what do the purse levels need to be in order to maximize the other factors or vice versa I suppose.
Reply With Quote