Stumbled across this...
http://www.philly.com/philly/sports/...odern_era.html
Howard, utley , Rollins and Polonco are better than Texieria, Cano, Jeter and Arod?
whoa....
simple method using 2009 VORP (which doesnt take D into consideration)
Howard 46.6
utley 67.5
Rollins 27.8
Polonco 15.0
tex 48.7
Cano 45.6
Jeter 65.6
Arod 49.7
It is a mismatch