Hmmmmm, i only had a quick look through, but i thought both Finsceal Beo and Sakhee's Secret desevred to be much higher in the list, especially Sakhee's who beat a lot of very good horses in the July Cup.
Why do you think the list is "comedy"? The people who work out these ratings are only doing there job.
Manduro is rated so highly partly because of his form from last year, and mainly because i think he has only be unplaced in one of his many Gr1 races, and any horses that can run consistantly well at the very top level deserve plenty of respect.
__________________
Avatar ~ Nicky Whelan 
and now we murderers because we kill time
|