Quote:
|
Originally Posted by ArlJim78
a closed border to me means no immigration, a controlled border means just that, a controlled documented immigration. like I said previously I really belive in an active immigration policy, one that brings many people to the US from a variety of countries, FAIRLY and with some security measures.
I don't claim to have all the answers on this issue, but on the border control part of it I do have some ideas that I would immediately pursue if I were in charge of things. I don't think its real complicated. In my mind what is going on is not much different than an invasion from a foreign country, admittedly one that we have allowed, or even invited. In this age of terror though it is not acceptable to have such a loose grasp on the border
Briefly:
Basically we need to really increase our border control assets. I would increase the US border patrol personnel in the region significantly. I would augment that with National guard deployments. I would look at the entire southern border not just specific pathes. I would install high tech hardware, cameras, drones, listening devices, etc, aimed at the border.
While doing this I would announce to Mexico that we will now be actively changing our posture and apprehending people. I would have a tough policy. like first offense, you are sent back. Second offense you're looking at some jail time.
What I think would be ideal is a large US "super" consulate in northern Mexico, where people that want to enter the US for work can be processed and given some type of work visa. You want to eliminate the demand for illegal entry by expanding the legal channels. When I enter Brasil on business I am fingerprinted and a photo is taken.
We need much more horsepower in terms of processing documents etc. We have now virtual gridlock in terms of passports.
We also will need active domestic enforcement against employers who hire illegals. the idea is to have visibilty, so that we can get an accurate count, and also I might add to be able to protect the rights of these workers. they are invisble now and therefore I think candidates for abuse.
These actions would stem the tide and channel the migration into legal path's.
Remember though that the border control issue is not only about migrant workers, its about keeping out unsavory types, criminals, terrorists, drug trade, customs control etc. As Somer said the big majority are just people that want work in order to support their families and have a decent life, and therefore are not a threat. I agree with that but my only point is that we have to have control over the numbers of people coming in, AND we need to be able to exclude certain people.
Left unchecked for too long, and an uncontrolled border is a recipe for ruin.
those are my thoughts, but I know that with that said none of it is easy.
|
ArlJim,
Thanks for taking the time to explain. You make some very interesting points.
I think the border should be controlled as well, but I don't really see that it can be. Since the "war on drugs" began so many years ago, are you aware that despite great efforts by many governmental agencies, less than 10% of illegal drugs (heroin, cocaine, marijuana) are intercepted.
I really don't have the answer to how the border can be controlled, nor do those that are attempting to control it.