[somerfrost]

Originally Posted by Buffymommy

ok, I agree with some but disagree with some others.


1. Jordin-If this girl doesn't win, this show is rigged.

2. Melinda-Very nice performance, but again, I will not buy an album of hers, even though I think she is an excellent performer.

3. Blake-I liked his performance. Was it worthy of Tim McGraw? Not really, but it was a nice performance. Even though I think he should have sang "Me and My Gang" by Rascal Flatts, it was a good performance overall.

4. Chris - A bit nasaly BUT country music is full of nasaly singers. Overall, I liked it.

5. Phil-OK performance. He should stick with country.

6. Lakisha-I like her I really do, but my theory use to be "DON'T SING A SONG THAT KELLY CLARKSON DOES". I have now amended it that to be "DON'T SING A SONG THAT KELLY OR CARRIE DOES". It really was awful and it showed she has a bit of a speech impediment.

7. Sangaya-GO HOME! That was downright PAINFUL to listen and watch.


JUST BUFFY'S OPINION. I want Sanjaya to go home, but since more than likely those girls that love those little "girlie" boys voted for him. I am worried about Lakisha, but I think it will be either Phil or Chris going home. But honestly, I think Phil deserves to go before Chris.

Everybody here (except for one flamer posting ugly stuff for a reaction) seems to agree pretty much on last night. Jordin was beautiful to watch AND listen to...she seems to have unlimited potential. I still think Melinda has a slight lead but she may be at her peak while Jordin just seems to get better every week. If America votes on talent and performance, it MUST come down to those two. I like LaKisha and respect her trying to make a life for herself and her baby but I'm afraid she's peaked and heading the wrong direction. America seems to be alternating boy/girl each week so a guy should leave this week. Phil is the obvious choice based on past (lack of) support but Chris did himself no favors last night...I will be very surprised if one of those two don't leave...of course it goes without saying that it should be Sanjaya.