Scuds I cannot make a case for Hallway (Albarado) being the better horse; either through the use of the past perfromances or in the actual running. True Jimmy was whacking left handed but jocks generally hit with the opposite hand to where the challenge is coming. The winner (St. Zarb) is a nice horse but Robbie had a whole track to get by and was held. The winner has now won three in a row. BBB