[Buffymommy]

Brian,


1. Agree with your assessment of Phil. But I did like him. It wasn't bad, but not great, but I do think he is improving. He actually started the song better this week.

2. Jared is better this week than last week. He actually shocked me with his vocals this week. I wasn't expecting him to be as good as he was.

3. AJ. I am sorry my negativity towards him didn't weaken in the least this week. I tried to listen to him and his voice, BUT he is just tooooooooo gay for me. No offense to gays, I have nothing against being gay. He is just to feminine for my taste. I like a guy to be a guy.

4. Sanjaya- If this dude doesn't go home, I will be very angry this week.

5. Chris S.- Redeemed himself to me a bit this week. I didn't like him attacking Simon last week. But honestly I didn't know he was married and I loved that he dedicated the song and performance to his wife. Those two actually make a very cute couple. His vocals were very good last night. I would say he was #2 last night.

6. Nick-what can I say about this dude? I don't like him. He sounds to nasaly to me. Didn't like it at all. I think he and Sanjaya need to pack their bags.

7. Blake- Honestly, I thought he was "so-so" last night. I didn't really like him but I didn't hate him either. He has to do more to win me over. I actually really liked him after Hollywood, but he has become boring IMO.

8. Brandon-JESUS WILL THESE AMERICAN IDOLS STOP SINGING CYNDI LAUPER? That is one of my all time fave songs. Anyone other than Cyndi butchers it!

9. Chris R. What can I say? I have a little crush. I like that he is from a very modest background. Who cares if he is from a trailer park. I LOVE BIG MAMMA! (hee hee maybe I am a little biased as my old german shepard mix was nicknamed "big mamma") But vocally, last night Chris was the best.

10. Sundance-Hasn't won me over yet. But I do like the guy. He is humble and did improve this week.

My top four (and yes, I did vote for these four):
Chris R.
Chris S.
Sundance
Phil


Bottom Four:
Sanjaya
Nick
AJ
Brandon

This is just my opinion.