what horse whould you rather have?
 

a ny bred

carson city by Toussaud 2 yr old colt


or

ky bred

mineshaft by classy n smart 2 yr old f

and why.

The filly. If both are flops on the track the filly will have more value as a broodmare.

i agree. altho out of toussaud is worth a second look. but overall, you'd have to take the gal.

The NY Bred, you'll clean up on State Bred Turf races.

If The Green Monkey can be a stud prospect, then I'd take the son of Toussaud, win some stakes races on turf (how many Toussaud progeny have failed?), and retire the horse and rake in the cash after a decent 3 year old season.

odd question.

i'd take the toussaud though. she is, in my book, one of the true great talents i've ever seen, had a breathtaking turn of foot, and turned out to be a fantastic producer.

i think her grandson, first defence, has some potential as a stallion.

Who would you rather own in Churchill 6th race:

Cheyenne Autumn or Sanctissima?