Eagles Thumping Giants
 

Where did these receivers come from that are making highlight play after play. First Jackson again then this rookie makes a first rate great catch in traffic.....They put up 30 in a half. What else can you want?

Sooner or later people are going to have to confront the idea that the Giants aren't that good.

Saying they aren't that good gives them too much credit.

This looks like pro versus college. Division II college.

How bad would they be without the NFL's best rookie?

they dont have Pat White.

KG knows who i am talking about

how bad would this team be without the NFL's best rookie
http://www.nfl.com/players/jairusbyr...e?id=BYR449897

Even worse.

Hakeem Nicks?? I have no idea who you are referring to

KG's guy Hakeem. you were busy last week while we were discussing this.

Instead of telling me he's not the best rookie, maybe you could tell me who is and then give me undeniable proof that he is. I'm only giving my opinion on the matter since there's no such thing as a fact but if it's indeed a fact that I'm wrong, please correct me.

So far Harvin is better.

As expected. Thanks.

Like I said, only 2 teams matter in the NFC

you disagree? What would make you think that your guy is better than Harvin has been? It really isnt close considering Harvin is one of the best return men in the league as well. Please explain to me why Nicks is or has been better?

Oh, that's how it works? I give my opinion. You tell me I'm wrong. Then, without explaining your opinion, I'm supposed to explain mine? That's ok. I'll pass. You can have Harvin. I'll take Nicks.

I'll take Harvin.

Unfortunately, so would I

What exactly did I do to get you in a huff? Harvin has more catches, more yards, more TD's, and fills two positions. I mean it is obvious stuff. And before you start with the Nicks was hurt stuff, Harvin has been playing banged up and sick. So Harvin it appears is more durable than Nicks as well. Enough?

And I think Nicks is good and who knows he may be great someday but KG insists that he is the best rookie bar none without much really "proving" it. I'm sure there are some defensive rookies that are doing at least as good as Phil pointed out but dont care enough to look.