Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Monmouth situation increasingly dire.. (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=44837)

Kasept 12-12-2011 02:53 PM

Monmouth situation increasingly dire..
 
The horsemen have caused Morris Bailey to walk away and Christie is issuing deadline threats.

http://www.mycentraljersey.com/artic...ed-by-investor

cmorioles 12-12-2011 03:53 PM

Is Christie lying about the horsemen's requesting a supplement after a handshake agreement? If not, seems the blame doesn't lie in his office.

cmorioles 12-12-2011 04:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cardus (Post 824614)
CM, I have no idea about what transpired, actually.

Yeah, shouldn't have quoted your post, was generic for anyone. I don't have any problem with politicians that don't want to subsidize horse racing.

NTamm1215 12-12-2011 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmorioles (Post 824623)
Yeah, shouldn't have quoted your post, was generic for anyone. I don't have any problem with politicians that don't want to subsidize horse racing.

This is exactly the problem. Christie has said that the horseman changed the handshake agreement, but they are not offering anything.

Cannon Shell 12-12-2011 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmorioles (Post 824612)
Is he lying about the horsemen's requesting a supplement after a handshake agreement? If not, seems the blame doesn't lie in his office.

That isnt what actually happened but hey why let a chance to take a shot at horsemen go to waste.

Cannon Shell 12-12-2011 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NTamm1215 (Post 824625)
This is exactly the problem. Christie has said that the horseman changed the handshake agreement, but they are not offering anything.

The horsemen didnt change anything as they had no power to change anything. What happened is that Gural realized by extending the Meadowlands TB dates to the thoroughbred horsemans association (as has been done the last few years) that by proxy he would have to share revenue with them (if off track wagering which has been proposed at the boondoggle mall and also slot revenue if the Meadowlands ever gets them as proposed by many Northern Jersey pols). When he complained to Christie they wanted to include language that precluded the horseman from sharing revenue. Naturally the horsemen's position is that this was the deal agreed upon, the other parties should have done their due dilegence. And while we (horsemen) dont always agree with the NJTHA and their leadership if the shoe was on the other foot the state would surely maintain their position. And the state of NJ doesnt mind keeping the profits from NJ bets while bitching that they are losing money on horse racing. To the state of NJ the OTB profits dont count as "horseracing" revenue.

pmayjr 12-13-2011 07:05 AM

so... Please educate me. Because I really don't understand...

This 5 million that Bailey put up to lease/manage the track. Was it really only 5 million? And what % of handle/overall revenue would the potential managing group get? Sorry if these questions are dumb but I seriously don't know...

Kasept 12-13-2011 12:31 PM

NJTHA Prez John Forbes on ATR this morning and clearly frustrated.

Made it sound like Christie is making any deal an impossible-to-nail-down moving target.

tector 12-13-2011 02:38 PM

Finally, a state more stupid than Florida when it comes to racing.

Congrats, NJ.

richard burch 12-13-2011 09:56 PM

here is a positive sign!!!

The 2012 VIP Season Pass & Parking is now on sale!

Just $85, the pass includes:

•Clubhouse and/or Grandstand Admission for every day of the 2012 meet
•Counts as "paid admission" for all promotional giveaways
•Includes admission for Haskell Day

The 2012 VIP Season Pass is the perfect gift for the racing fan in your family that calls Monmouth Park home for the summer!

i do feel it will get worked out

Immanuel Kant 12-17-2011 08:35 AM

They'll be running for purses generated from handle, while PA and NY get subsidized.

no handle no purses...no purses no quality.......no quality no handle

cmorioles 12-17-2011 09:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell (Post 824655)
That isnt what actually happened but hey why let a chance to take a shot at horsemen go to waste.

I asked a question. Obviously somebody isn't telling the truth.

cmorioles 12-17-2011 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Immanuel Kant (Post 825866)
They'll be running for purses generated from handle, while PA and NY get subsidized.

no handle no purses...no purses no quality.......no quality no handle

They'll close in no time, or run at Beulah levels.

Cannon Shell 12-17-2011 10:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmorioles (Post 825876)
I asked a question. Obviously somebody isn't telling the truth.

The horsemen aren't politically saavy enough to understand that lying is ok when negotiating in the press

Cannon Shell 12-17-2011 10:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmorioles (Post 825877)
They'll close in no time, or run at Beulah levels.

The deal signed is simply to save face and give them more time to reach a real deal. There is no chance they will run all those days but in the current climate the horsemen aren't going to feel comfortable waiving the days requirement as it is a negotiating piece and the Gov has no issues with going back on his word.

cmorioles 12-17-2011 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell (Post 825885)
The deal signed is simply to save face and give them more time to reach a real deal. There is no chance they will run all those days but in the current climate the horsemen aren't going to feel comfortable waiving the days requirement as it is a negotiating piece and the Gov has no issues with going back on his word.

I hope the horsemen saved up their pennies from the elite meet, because times are going to be tough in NJ no matter how this plays out this year.

richard burch 12-20-2011 10:10 PM

It's Alive! It's Alive!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by richard burch (Post 824854)
here is a positive sign!!!

The 2012 VIP Season Pass & Parking is now on sale!

Just $85, the pass includes:

•Clubhouse and/or Grandstand Admission for every day of the 2012 meet
•Counts as "paid admission" for all promotional giveaways
•Includes admission for Haskell Day

The 2012 VIP Season Pass is the perfect gift for the racing fan in your family that calls Monmouth Park home for the summer!

i do feel it will get worked out





http://blogs.app.com/capitolquickies...-open-in-2012/

State officials and representatives of a horsemen’s group agreed on a deal late Monday to keep Monmouth Park open in 2012, narrowly beating Gov. Chris Christie’s deadline to have a contract in place.

i guess fatso finally found the envelope under his desk.

GoIrish 12-21-2011 06:47 AM

Now I can order my season pass.

MaTH716 12-21-2011 08:07 AM

Quote:

The gross purses for 2012 will be about $4 million shy of maintaining the track’s stakes program, including the Haskell, which receives national TV coverage and is attended by more than 30,000 racing fans each year.
If this doesn't come through, they might as well board the place up.

freddymo 12-21-2011 10:17 AM

The state of NJ should be ashamed. They had a magnificent concept, and it was a terriffic meet to attend bet and be part of. I swear I dont get it.

jms62 12-21-2011 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freddymo (Post 826617)
The state of NJ should be ashamed. They had a magnificent concept, and it was a terriffic meet to attend bet and be part of. I swear I dont get it.

What is not to get. One could surmise that Christie has lots of "Friends" in Atlantic City. One also could surmise by his not squashing the absolute debacle Xanadu project, he has a lot of developer friends. Wait until Sports Betting comes to NJ and they decide that it will only be allowed in Atlantic City even though the Race tracks have been the only game in town for Betting on a sporting event.

MaTH716 12-21-2011 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jms62 (Post 826620)
What is not to get. One could surmise that Christie has lots of "Friends" in Atlantic City. One also could surmise by his not squashing the absolute debacle Xanadu project, he has a lot of developer friends. Wait until Sports Betting comes to NJ and they decide that it will only be allowed in Atlantic City even though the Race tracks have been the only game in town for Betting on a sporting event.

At this point, don't they almost have to go through with the rest of the project (whatever it is)? The structure has been up forever, although I have no idea what the current plans are and what it looks like inside. All they would be doing by tearing it down is burning every single dollar they invested into the project. It probably is a lose lose proposition, but at this point maybe they can still salvage the place as a mall.

jms62 12-21-2011 10:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaTH716 (Post 826623)
At this point, don't they almost have to go through with the rest of the project (whatever it is)? The structure has been up forever, although I have no idea what the current plans are and what it looks like inside. All they would be doing by tearing it down is burning every single dollar they invested into the project. It probably is a lose lose proposition, but at this point maybe they can still salvage the place as a mall.

Say you bought Enron at its high, would you continue investing in it all the way down to zero? At what point do you stop throwing good money after bad?

MaTH716 12-21-2011 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jms62 (Post 826625)
Say you bought Enron at its high, would you continue investing in it all the way down to zero? At what point do you stop throwing good money after bad?

I think that's a bad analogy J. It's not like they have zero. They still have a massive structure with parking that (seems to be) built already. Not to mention that they now have a mass transit option to the place as well. I just think ditching at this point might by more of a colossal waste than finally following through with the project. Obviously if it's a mirage and it's nowhere near being done and the price tag is more ridiculous than ever, then yes I think it should be scrapped.

freddymo 12-21-2011 11:19 AM

I thought it was a great idea. I thought that if the State allocated 100mil over 5 years to reinvent the horse model it COULD have worked. Instead they shot there load in a summer.

Cannon Shell 12-21-2011 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freddymo (Post 826640)
I thought it was a great idea. I thought that if the State allocated 100mil over 5 years to reinvent the horse model it COULD have worked. Instead they shot there load in a summer.

The thing is though Freddy it wasnt the states money anyway. The money came from a deal between Atlantic city casinos and the track. Monmouth/horseracing doesnt lose money for the state. The NJSEA loses money but it is really has virtually no usefulness at this point anyway

freddymo 12-22-2011 09:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell (Post 826670)
The thing is though Freddy it wasnt the states money anyway. The money came from a deal between Atlantic city casinos and the track. Monmouth/horseracing doesnt lose money for the state. The NJSEA loses money but it is really has virtually no usefulness at this point anyway

It was the last of the casino supplement and I am ok with the Casino's pulling that off the table. Atlantic City is totally screwed. You have to understand that AC grew a huge infrastructure when the US was devoid of gambling. Now the country is loaded with gambling and the State does have to deal with ten of thousands of jobs that need some consideration.

The key is not the money the casinos were giving the tracks, the key was reinventing a sustainable model for an industry. IMO if the State invested in racing for 5 years at MP and atificially supported purses with seed money the product could have been groomed in time to be self sustaining and ultimately OK for the horseman, bettors and the State.

Government is suppose to invest in things which can spur growth. having a reasonably healthy horse business in NJ that is sustainable is worthy of investment. Just busting a nut of 30 million in a summer was silly. Yet what that 30 mil showed us is that big purses with big fields is a product people willingly wager on. As for 80k allowance races that still had 6 horses well that is a function of horse flesh and too many of the same horses with to few a trainer which over 5 years could have rectified itself with some work.

With NYRA gettng slot revenue will see if they are prudent enough to push for less dates, of course we all realize that what NYRA wants to do isnt always what the idiots who control them think they should do? Let's hope they try like heck to do the right thing.

Cannon Shell 12-22-2011 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freddymo (Post 826864)
It was the last of the casino supplement and I am ok with the Casino's pulling that off the table. Atlantic City is totally screwed. You have to understand that AC grew a huge infrastructure when the US was devoid of gambling. Now the country is loaded with gambling and the State does have to deal with ten of thousands of jobs that need some consideration.

The key is not the money the casinos were giving the tracks, the key was reinventing a sustainable model for an industry. IMO if the State invested in racing for 5 years at MP and atificially supported purses with seed money the product could have been groomed in time to be self sustaining and ultimately OK for the horseman, bettors and the State.

Government is suppose to invest in things which can spur growth. having a reasonably healthy horse business in NJ that is sustainable is worthy of investment. Just busting a nut of 30 million in a summer was silly. Yet what that 30 mil showed us is that big purses with big fields is a product people willingly wager on. As for 80k allowance races that still had 6 horses well that is a function of horse flesh and too many of the same horses with to few a trainer which over 5 years could have rectified itself with some work.

With NYRA gettng slot revenue will see if they are prudent enough to push for less dates, of course we all realize that what NYRA wants to do isnt always what the idiots who control them think they should do? Let's hope they try like heck to do the right thing.

I hve no problem with the casino wanting to end the payments. However the reason that they were making them is still unresolved and a rational idea would be to form some sort of partnership to construct a casino at the Meadowlands that would help everyone. Of course AC doesnt want to do this because they are too greedy to share the profits, The Gov doesnt want to do this because he sways the way the casinos wind blows (obviously not an easy thing to accomplish considering his bulk) and lets face it the 1st 2 parties would rather bankrupt the "competition" before partnering with them.

pointman 12-22-2011 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell (Post 826897)
I hve no problem with the casino wanting to end the payments. However the reason that they were making them is still unresolved and a rational idea would be to form some sort of partnership to construct a casino at the Meadowlands that would help everyone. Of course AC doesnt want to do this because they are too greedy to share the profits, The Gov doesnt want to do this because he sways the way the casinos wind blows (obviously not an easy thing to accomplish considering his bulk) and lets face it the 1st 2 parties would rather bankrupt the "competition" before partnering with them.

As I understand it, the subsidies by the casinos were agreed to in exchange for the State not allowing casinos elsewhere in the State, partiuclarly the Meadowlands, which would compete with Atlantic City. Now that AC is really in the sh!tter and has competition from everywhere surrounding it, Delaware, Pennsylvania and New York, they don't want to pay the subsidy yet AC still wants no competition within the State of New Jersey.

The casinos are obviously in the politicians pockets (and this is not limited to one party), yet I'm not sure why NJ government would not want to allow the racetracks to open casinos to subsidize both the horse racing industry (so they can at least compete with their neighbors) and raise valuable tax money for the politicians to spend. Lord knows that politicians in the Northeast can NEVER spend enough money.

Cannon Shell 12-22-2011 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pointman (Post 826943)
As I understand it, the subsidies by the casinos were agreed to in exchange for the State not allowing casinos elsewhere in the State, partiuclarly the Meadowlands, which would compete with Atlantic City. Now that AC is really in the sh!tter and has competition from everywhere surrounding it, Delaware, Pennsylvania and New York, they don't want to pay the subsidy yet AC still wants no competition within the State of New Jersey.

The casinos are obviously in the politicians pockets (and this is not limited to one party), yet I'm not sure why NJ government would not want to allow the racetracks to open casinos to subsidize both the horse racing industry (so they can at least compete with their neighbors) and raise valuable tax money for the politicians to spend. Lord knows that politicians in the Northeast can NEVER spend enough money.

Because they can't make enough money for themselves if they have to split it with millionaire horse owners.

pointman 12-22-2011 03:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell (Post 826945)
Because they can't make enough money for themselves if they have to split it with millionaire horse owners.

Therein lies the horseman's problem. The AC casinos (Donald Trump in particular) are a large reason why the Aqueduct casino took 10 years to ultimately get the full go ahead. It is a shame that horseman are being left in the cold since they cannot line the politicians pockets like the casinos can.

richard burch 12-22-2011 03:50 PM

Congratulations A.C.!!!
 
PENNSYLVANIA SURPASSES ATLANTIC CITY FOR FIRST TIME IN MONTHLY CASINO REVENUE.


http://sboanj.com/index.asp?Key=2553

great job christie! thanks for pissing away the tax money you saved from the horse racing industry "extortionists" and dumping into the shithole that is a.c.



i believe this will only help to get slots in the tracks in n.j. just be patient. the fat man just hasn't recieved his goody bag yet.

freddymo 12-22-2011 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell (Post 826897)
I hve no problem with the casino wanting to end the payments. However the reason that they were making them is still unresolved and a rational idea would be to form some sort of partnership to construct a casino at the Meadowlands that would help everyone. Of course AC doesnt want to do this because they are too greedy to share the profits, The Gov doesnt want to do this because he sways the way the casinos wind blows (obviously not an easy thing to accomplish considering his bulk) and lets face it the 1st 2 parties would rather bankrupt the "competition" before partnering with them.

Another casino isnt the answer..its just another place to rob people.

pointman 12-22-2011 05:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freddymo (Post 826980)
Another casino isnt the answer..its just another place to rob people.

While you are right about this, other than NJ pumping $30 million year for the next 4 or 5 years to sustain the successful model used for 1 year until the purses could support such a meet going forward, how can NJ horse racing attempt to compete with New York, Delaware and Pennsylvania?

freddymo 12-22-2011 05:10 PM

[quote=pointman;826981]While you are right about this, other than NJ pumping $30 million year for the next 4 or 5 years to sustain the successful model used for 1 year until the purses could support such a meet going forward, how can NJ horse racing attempt to compete with New York, Delaware and Pennsylvania?[/QUOTE


Save NY which is the mecca of racing who cares about Pa/Delaware racing. the horses suck and the handles are a joke. Building another casino is silly. You have to think outside the box the State should recogize that investing BS (100 mil/5 years) money into the sport COULD have a lot of real value long term. Build a small cottage horse business that is attractive or at least sustainable for 12-16 week a year. You have to invest and seed an industry its what governmen is suppose to do.

richard burch 12-22-2011 05:15 PM

in the end you will see a few less casinos in a.c. and a casino in the meadowlands and maybe monmouth.

i'm not good picking horses but that is a lock.

MaTH716 12-22-2011 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by richard burch (Post 826962)
PENNSYLVANIA SURPASSES ATLANTIC CITY FOR FIRST TIME IN MONTHLY CASINO REVENUE.


http://sboanj.com/index.asp?Key=2553

great job christie! thanks for pissing away the tax money you saved from the horse racing industry "extortionists" and dumping into the shithole that is a.c.



i believe this will only help to get slots in the tracks in n.j. just be patient. the fat man just hasn't recieved his goody bag yet.


What would you do regarding Atlantic City if you were the governor? Keep in mind the amount of jobs that are involved with the hotels/casinos.

Cannon Shell 12-22-2011 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaTH716 (Post 826987)
What would you do regarding Atlantic City if you were the governor? Keep in mind the amount of jobs that are involved with the hotels/casinos.

The problem is that pouring money into AC is a losing bet and everyone seems to know this (probably including the Gov). There just isnt much reason to go there anymore and the setup they have there spends far too much infrastructurewise versus the competition. Obviously politicians have different outlooks on things than we do but AC is basically dead unless they radically change something.

Cannon Shell 12-22-2011 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freddymo (Post 826980)
Another casino isnt the answer..its just another place to rob people.

Of course it is the answer. You need to have a casino where the people are and the people aren't in AC anymore. If the tracks are a partner on the thing and are allowed to do things the right way (obviously no guarantee of this) then the thing could eventually thrive. But the state wants to take from racing not give and realistically there is no chance that a state handout would be used any differently than it is now. The can would just be kicked down the road again.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.