Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Big Brown headed to Monmouth (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=24637)

letswastemoney 08-21-2008 06:21 AM

Big Brown headed to Monmouth
 
http://drf.com/news/article/97460.html


He's going to compete in the newly created Monmouth Stakes 1 1/8 miles on turf $500,000 if he runs.

fpsoxfan 08-21-2008 06:39 AM

Good for him. I was once a big fan of this horse, but now I've had it with the connections. The weasals should put their money where their mouth is and face off with Curlin.

ninetoone 08-21-2008 08:20 AM

If that day comes, Curlin is gonna spank his ass.

blackthroatedwind 08-21-2008 08:54 AM

For a camp that claimed they had a better horse than Curlin in every way they sure are going to unusual lengths to avoid him.

ArlJim78 08-21-2008 09:04 AM

no better way to prove that your horse is the best then to run him in the storied Monmouth Stakes.

blackthroatedwind 08-21-2008 09:05 AM

It's the nouveau thing to do.

VOL JACK 08-21-2008 09:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind
For a camp that claimed they had a better horse than Curlin in every way they sure are going to unusual lengths to avoid him.

Status quo for them, lie to anyone that will listen. Then claim to be the good guys.

parsixfarms 08-21-2008 10:03 AM

Nice to see how these New Yorkers support New York racing.

Benny Leger 08-21-2008 10:50 AM

It seems to me they have nothing to lose,and everything to gain, by running against Curlin. I don't think BB would win, but If he did beat Curlin....

ddthetide 08-21-2008 11:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VOL JACK
Status quo for them, lie to anyone that will listen. Then claim to be the good guys.

steve had them on the radio the other day. hope Steve took a shower after the interview, they are just slimy to listen too.

Quiet Chris 08-21-2008 12:09 PM

Big Brown is nothing more than an overrated 3yr old that was beating the absolutely worst crop of 3yr olds in decades. Horses that were winning Derby preps and running in the derby are now getting trounced by slow NY breds.


I would love nothing more than to see Mambo in Seattle tear off wins in the Travers, Goodwood, and BCC and take the 3yr old eclipse and HOY away from Big Brown. Being a Kingmambo he has a shot. Although the O'Briens Kingmambo is probably going to romp in the Classic.

ateamstupid 08-21-2008 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Quiet Chris
Big Brown is nothing more than an overrated 3yr old that was beating the absolutely worst crop of 3yr olds in decades. Horses that were winning Derby preps and running in the derby are now getting trounced by slow NY breds.


I would love nothing more than to see Mambo in Seattle tear off wins in the Travers, Goodwood, and BCC and take the 3yr old eclipse and HOY away from Big Brown. Being a Kingmambo he has a shot. Although the O'Briens Kingmambo is probably going to romp in the Classic.

I wish you'd stop mushing Mambo in Seattle.

Danzig 08-21-2008 05:20 PM

it's for three and up. i think curlin ought to show up. after all, didn't asmussen say that curlin always made a better effort on his second go 'round on a course? of course that wouldn't really be following the letter of that law exactly, but it would be curlins second start on turf.
what the hell...jackson is so hot for the face off, do it here!

AeWingnut 08-21-2008 05:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig
it's for three and up. i think curlin ought to show up. after all, didn't asmussen say that curlin always made a better effort on his second go 'round on a course? of course that wouldn't really be following the letter of that law exactly, but it would be curlins second start on turf.
what the hell...jackson is so hot for the face off, do it here!


yes, Jackson should show up with Curlin. Hell, Big Brown looks to be done as it is. I imagine if Curlin does run there's a chance they could race each other into submission and Red Rocks or someone would be there to pick up the pieces.

ateamstupid 08-21-2008 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig
it's for three and up. i think curlin ought to show up. after all, didn't asmussen say that curlin always made a better effort on his second go 'round on a course? of course that wouldn't really be following the letter of that law exactly, but it would be curlins second start on turf.
what the hell...jackson is so hot for the face off, do it here!

You don't cater to the guy who's been talking the smack. You make him either come to you or look foolish. Besides, let's see what I'd rather win.. Woodward/Jockey Club Gold Cup.. Monmouth Stakes.. Really a toss-up.

Danzig 08-21-2008 07:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ateamstupid
You don't cater to the guy who's been talking the smack. You make him either come to you or look foolish. Besides, let's see what I'd rather win.. Woodward/Jockey Club Gold Cup.. Monmouth Stakes.. Really a toss-up.

oh, i'd rather win the woodward/jcgc as well. but i wonder how much money monmouth would put up if jackson expressed interest? i just wonder what the reaction from ieah would be if jackson announced curlin was going to show up. would love to be a fly on the wall...

docicu3 08-21-2008 09:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArlJim78
no better way to prove that your horse is the best then to run him in the storied Monmouth Stakes.


What's the deal with the purse jumping from 200K to half a million if Big Brown shows up. Talk about Tiger Woodslike appearance fees. How often have you seen a purse go up 1.5 times the original value for getting in the gate in this country. And why there? Wouldn't it make more sense to try and run at least one race on poly if you are even remotely interested in conquering the Classic?

SniperSB23 08-21-2008 09:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by docicu3
What's the deal with the purse jumping from 200K to half a million if Big Brown shows up. Talk about Tiger Woodslike appearance fees. How often have you seen a purse go up 1.5 times the original value for getting in the gate in this country. And why there? Wouldn't it make more sense to try and run at least one race on poly if you are even remotely interested in conquering the Classic?

Why would he want to face Asmussen's best synthetic horse and lose?

docicu3 08-21-2008 11:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
Why would he want to face Asmussen's best synthetic horse and lose?


Than you can't say your the best if you have to duck the Breeders Cup completely or the Classic specifically. What's BB gonna do that weekend??....if they take to the green they'll find a little different gathering than a Saratoga MSW.

They can say what they want but BB's last was far from the efforts in Ky and Fla. The connections want to be crowned but don't have a king who wants to earn it. They gain nothing running in Jersey but the purse....respect is about winning BIG races not earnings. I'm surprised the connections don't get to fill the field with hand picked claimers so BB doesn't crack a sweat.

dalakhani 08-21-2008 11:48 PM

Jess Jackson was making a lot of challenges
 
If he wants the Brown horse, he knows where to find him come mid september.

I just dont understand how Jackson gets a pass for ducking the BCC and Big Brown's connections get hell for wanting to wait until the championship for a showdown.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 12:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by docicu3
Than you can't say your the best if you have to duck the Breeders Cup completely or the Classic specifically. What's BB gonna do that weekend??....if they take to the green they'll find a little different gathering than a Saratoga MSW.

They can say what they want but BB's last was far from the efforts in Ky and Fla. The connections want to be crowned but don't have a king who wants to earn it. They gain nothing running in Jersey but the purse....respect is about winning BIG races not earnings. I'm surprised the connections don't get to fill the field with hand picked claimers so BB doesn't crack a sweat.

I was talking about Student Council who will be the first American based finisher at the BC, which probably means 5th place.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 12:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
If he wants the Brown horse, he knows where to find him come mid september.

I just dont understand how Jackson gets a pass for ducking the BCC and Big Brown's connections get hell for wanting to wait until the championship for a showdown.

I just don't understand how anyone can find it such a bizarre concept to settle the championship on the dirt like every American championship up until now has been settled. If Iavarone calls Jackson out right now for the Clark and Jackson doesn't show up then I will 100% blame Jackson. But while they keep trying to force the race on turf or synthetics while Curlin's connections are willing to square off on dirt it is a joke. IEAH is scared of facing Curlin on the dirt, and they should be.

dalakhani 08-22-2008 12:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
I just don't understand how anyone can find it such a bizarre concept to settle the championship on the dirt like every American championship up until now has been settled. If Iavarone calls Jackson out right now for the Clark and Jackson doesn't show up then I will 100% blame Jackson. But while they keep trying to force the race on turf or synthetics while Curlin's connections are willing to square off on dirt it is a joke. IEAH is scared of facing Curlin on the dirt, and they should be.

If Curlin is the best horse and they were planning the ARC, surface shouldnt matter.

A win over Big Brown for Curlin, would mean more than another victory in a "grade 1" over the likes of Baracola or Evening Attire.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 01:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
If Curlin is the best horse and they were planning the ARC, surface shouldnt matter.

A win over Big Brown for Curlin, would mean more than another victory in a "grade 1" over the likes of Baracola or Evening Attire.

Curlin tried the turf and was just good on it, they intelligently abandoned the Arc plans after it. They have absolutely no reason now to have him set foot on it again unless they are serious about a 5yo campaign.

What would mean something would be for Big Brown to come to the dirt and take on Curlin. I beg them, right now, throw down the guantlet and declare they want to meet at the Clark. If Jackson doesn't show up then he's the pu$$y. As long as IEAH keeps trying to, for the first time in American history determine the championship on something other than dirt, then they are being the pussies.

dalakhani 08-22-2008 01:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
Curlin tried the turf and was just good on it, they intelligently abandoned the Arc plans after it. They have absolutely no reason now to have him set foot on it again unless they are serious about a 5yo campaign.

What would mean something would be for Big Brown to come to the dirt and take on Curlin. I beg them, right now, throw down the guantlet and declare they want to meet at the Clark. If Jackson doesn't show up then he's the pu$$y. As long as IEAH keeps trying to, for the first time in American history determine the championship on something other than dirt, then they are being the pussies.

IEAH didnt set up the championship this way. They are just going along with it.

A shame that the "champ" cant.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 01:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
IEAH didnt set up the championship this way. They are just going along with it.

A shame that the "champ" cant.

IEAH wouldn't go to the Travers cause they might get beat.

IEAH wouldn't go to the Woodward cause they would get beat.

IEAH didn't throw down the gauntlet and say they wanted to meet Curlin in the Mass Cap cause they would get beat.

IEAH wouldn't go to the JCGC cause they would get beat.

And IEAH won't say they'll show up at the Clark to settle the score cause they would get beat.

Great "champion". I'll vote for Anak Nakal who beat Big Brown in the test of champions. And I can't wait for Einstein/Red Giant/Cosmonaut/Out of Control to show up on 9/13 and show Big Brown just how sorry this 3yo crop is.

dalakhani 08-22-2008 01:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
IEAH wouldn't go to the Travers cause they might get beat.

IEAH wouldn't go to the Woodward cause they would get beat.

IEAH didn't throw down the gauntlet and say they wanted to meet Curlin in the Mass Cap cause they would get beat.

IEAH wouldn't go to the JCGC cause they would get beat.

And IEAH won't say they'll show up at the Clark to settle the score cause they would get beat.

Great "champion". I'll vote for Anak Nakal who beat Big Brown in the test of champions. And I can't wait for Einstein/Red Giant/Cosmonaut/Out of Control to show up on 9/13 and show Big Brown just how sorry this 3yo crop is.

I cant wait for Big Brown to show up on BC day...a place that it looks like the "champ" won't be.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 01:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
I cant wait for Big Brown to show up on BC day...a place that it looks like the "champ" won't be.

nor the 3yo filly champ and possibly not the defending Distaff champ and maybe not even the runner up. Should be a great BC to see Europe and Japan show how far superior they are to the best in the California claiming ranks.

dalakhani 08-22-2008 01:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
nor the 3yo filly champ and possibly not the defending Distaff champ and maybe not even the runner up. Should be a great BC to see Europe and Japan show how far superior they are to the best in the California claiming ranks.

Shipping to california has long been an excuse for east coast based horses to duck the BC when it is out west. Now they have the poly as well.

ateamstupid 08-22-2008 01:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
If he wants the Brown horse, he knows where to find him come mid september.

I just dont understand how Jackson gets a pass for ducking the BCC and Big Brown's connections get hell for wanting to wait until the championship for a showdown.

So let me get this straight.. The onus is on Jackson to send his ALREADY PROVEN champion horse to a fake stakes on a surface they've already smartly abandoned to face a three-year-old whose connections have have constantly spoken out of line.

What the hell is in it for Jackson, and for that matter, what is in it for him to try Curlin on synthetics, where his horse (as many have done) will potentially run lousy and damage his legacy with the idiots who put synthetic on the same level as dirt.

I don't get it. Synthetic surfaces have been a boardwide joke around here, and now when Jackson doesn't want to risk his horse hating the tires, he's being a chicken.

Big Brown's supposed to be a freak on dirt. So what the hell was the problem with the Woodward? And what would've been the problem with the JCGC? You really think that if IEAH had announced that they were going to the JCGC, Curlin wouldn't have been there?

But no, they're taking their "superhorse" to a fraudulent turf stake at Monmouth. Great drama.. You might as well take the freaking horse to Finger Lakes. Either way, they'll be creating a race for you with little to no incentive for anyone else to show up. Big Brown is on the run, and Curlin, who's already proven his mettle, isn't the one who should be chasing.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 01:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ateamstupid
So let me get this straight.. The onus is on Jackson to send his ALREADY PROVEN champion horse to a fake stakes on a surface they've already smartly abandoned to face a three-year-old whose connections have have constantly spoken out of line.

What the hell is in it for Jackson, and for that matter, what is in it for him to try Curlin on synthetics, where his horse (as many have done) will potentially run lousy and damage his legacy with the idiots who put synthetic on the same level as dirt.

I don't get it. Synthetic surfaces have been a boardwide joke around here, and now when Jackson doesn't want to risk his horse hating the tires, he's being a chicken.

Big Brown's supposed to be a freak on dirt. So what the hell was the problem with the Woodward? And what would've been the problem with the JCGC? You really think that if IEAH had announced that they were going to the JCGC, Curlin wouldn't have been there?

But no, they're taking their "superhorse" to a fraudulent turf stake at Monmouth. Great drama.. You might as well take the freaking horse to Finger Lakes. Either way, they'll be creating a race for you with little to no incentive for anyone else to show up. Big Brown is on the run, and Curlin, who's already proven his mettle, isn't the one who should be chasing.

So let me get this straight....you are up at 3AM now but when out in Toga you have to run home with Mrs Ateam at midnight?

ateamstupid 08-22-2008 02:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
So let me get this straight....you are up at 3AM now but when out in Toga you have to run home with Mrs Ateam at midnight?

:rolleyes: I'm pretty sure that you know that there was a serious reason I was with whatever she wanted to do that weekend.. Way more important than this stuff. Or if you don't know, trust me.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 02:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ateamstupid
:rolleyes: I'm pretty sure that you know that there was a serious reason I was with whatever she wanted to do that weekend.. Way more important than this stuff. Or if you don't know, trust me.

No, I totally know, just busting your balls for being up at 3 AM.

ateamstupid 08-22-2008 02:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
No, I totally know, just busting your balls for being up at 3 AM.

I just came back from your favorite spot, Down the Hatch. Lost a beer pong game in Double OT. It was brutal.

SniperSB23 08-22-2008 02:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ateamstupid
I just came back from your favorite spot, Down the Hatch. Lost a beer pong game in Double OT. It was brutal.

That sucks dude, I gotta get back there, still undefeated lifetime. You coming up closing weekend? Sorry I totally bitched out Alabama Sunday, just did not want to deal with the spinners and the crappy card.

ateamstupid 08-22-2008 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
That sucks dude, I gotta get back there, still undefeated lifetime. You coming up closing weekend? Sorry I totally bitched out Alabama Sunday, just did not want to deal with the spinners and the crappy card.

Probably not in regards to closing weekend, but we'll see how Travers day goes. I figured you were developing a sleeping disorder since you showed up Alabama Day at 3:00, then were M.I.A. on Sunday. It's cool though, I had to catch a 7:20 train back to the city anyway.

Hickory Hill Hoff 08-22-2008 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fpsoxfan
Good for him. I was once a big fan of this horse, but now I've had it with the connections. The weasals should put their money where their mouth is and face off with Curlin.

:rolleyes:




:D

RollerDoc 08-22-2008 07:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
If he wants the Brown horse, he knows where to find him come mid september.

I just dont understand how Jackson gets a pass for ducking the BCC and Big Brown's connections get hell for wanting to wait until the championship for a showdown.


Exactly...........This is Big Brown's year. Let Curlin come to him. Big Brown has already solidified top 3 yr old. When he wins BCC, I can't wait for the backlash when he wins HOY.

RollerDoc 08-22-2008 07:28 PM

For a horse that has won five out of six Grade 1 races including the Derby and Preakness, how is this horse so disrespected by some of you? If you want to disrespect Big Brown's connections, I get that, but this has been a very good quality horse for us to enjoy this year.

Since the Preakness (5-0), he gets so much blustering on here. Here's what happened since then:

How about a pass on The Belmont? Gimme a break. Third race in five weeks and who knows why he didn't show up, just speculation. But it wasn't the same Big Brown. You don't think he would normally beat Da'Tara a horse that finished the Florida Derby when Big Brown was a zipcode past the finish line?

And then there was The Haskell that hardly any on here give him credit for. His chasing down Coal Play to win is very similar to Affirmed chasing the front running Sensitive Prince in the last 100 yards in the Jim Dandy that Laz Barrera considered one of Affirmed's finest efforts. Big Brown did the same thing and gets little credit.


Memo to Big Brown Bashers........."Give it a rest."

Cannon Shell 08-22-2008 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RollerDoc
For a horse that has won five out of six Grade 1 races including the Derby and Preakness, how is this horse so disrespected by some of you? If you want to disrespect Big Brown's connections, I get that, but this has been a very good quality horse for us to enjoy this year.

Since the Preakness (5-0), he gets so much blustering on here. Here's what happened since then:

How about a pass on The Belmont? Gimme a break. Third race in five weeks and who knows why he didn't show up, just speculation. But it wasn't the same Big Brown. You don't think he would normally beat Da'Tara a horse that finished the Florida Derby when Big Brown was a zipcode past the finish line?

And then there was The Haskell that hardly any on here give him credit for. His chasing down Coal Play to win is very similar to Affirmed chasing the front running Sensitive Prince in the last 100 yards in the Jim Dandy that Laz Barrera considered one of Affirmed's finest efforts. Big Brown did the same thing and gets little credit.


Memo to Big Brown Bashers........."Give it a rest."

Coal Play = Sensitive Prince? In what regard other than both being thoroughbreds?

The three year old crop sucks, the connections brashness make him very hard to root for, he is already assured of being retired after this year and he simply isnt that talented in terms of past champions. No one is saying that he is a 10 claimer but if you dont understand why people would not buy into the "greatness" of BB or his chances of beating Curlin, I am wondering what you have been following this year?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.