Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Monmouth Crowd Larger than Belmont Crowd (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23923)

Strategic Mission 07-13-2008 12:28 PM

Monmouth Crowd Larger than Belmont Crowd
 
Belmont Attendance 8,428
Monmouth Attendance 8,751

On a day when a returning HOY raced at Belmont against two BCT winners, Monmouth Park had a larger attendance than Belmont? Does NY really think that slots at Belmont aren't necessary or that a new person should head the marketing operation?

Horse Racing is easily the most poorly marketed sport in america. ESPN News? Pathetic.

Hickory Hill Hoff 07-13-2008 12:42 PM

They keep "dropping the ball" ......:D

philcski 07-13-2008 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Strategic Mission
Belmont Attendance 8,428
Monmouth Attendance 8,751

On a day when a returning HOY raced at Belmont against two BCT winners, Monmouth Park had a larger attendance than Belmont? Does NY really think that slots at Belmont aren't necessary or that a new person should head the marketing operation?

Horse Racing is easily the most poorly marketed sport in america. ESPN News? Pathetic.

And admission and parking was FREE yesterday at Belmont...

Bigsmc 07-13-2008 01:01 PM

The only way on track attendance will become relevant again would be to shut off all of the ADW's.

It's all about handle, not attendance.

dalakhani 07-13-2008 01:01 PM

Monmouth has working toilets...that is good for a few thousand alone.

Strategic Mission 07-13-2008 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bigsmc
The only way on track attendance will become relevant again would be to shut off all of the ADW's.

It's all about handle, not attendance.

It sort of is all about handle, but I can assure you tracks like Saratoga and Del Mar make a fortune with the money people at the track spend.

Belmont is a total waste of a very attractive resource. They could turn it into an upscale casino and the place would be packed every weekend. It is close enough to the city, and located on LI where there is plenty of money.

You could have big name concerts and a casino and racing if they really wanted it.

Instead it is really only used 1 race a year, and that is only if a TC is involved.

It is basically a parking lot for car salesman. No joke.

I would imagine the Atlantic City have paid off enough NY politicians to keep it from ever being a nice venue.

GenuineRisk 07-13-2008 02:53 PM

The NYRA also does a terrible job of promoting- the only reason I found out admission was free on Saturday was because I went onto the NYRA website to check out post times. So only people planning on going anyway found out it was free.

I know Curlin was cleared to run with barely a week before the race, but I can't believe they couldn't have thrown together some cheap TV ads and run them on the local stations. I thought the same thing at last year's Belmont- they got a great male vs. female angle and couldn't get an ad together for a few days before the Belmont?

the_fat_man 07-13-2008 03:02 PM

MTH has a LIVE STREAM of their races while NYRA doesn't even offer replays or live audio. Time to catch up with the new technology. (And it's not about the OTB thing because they weren't streaming before.) It's all about CONVENIENCE. People are typically more apt to 'work' in front of their computer rather than their tv.

Bobby Fischer 07-13-2008 03:05 PM

**** slots
 
The curlin race should have been broadcast on ESPN, Live at 8pm EST with Al Michaels, Stuart Scott, and Durkin on the mic.
There should have been prominent ads for trucks and alcohol on the jockeys, horses and safety rails. We should have been hearing the announcers wax about the versatility of Curlin, the greatness of Red Rocks, and the Broadcast should have been "commercial free" with live wagering on ESPN through the NTRA Call-a-bet/Internet wagering platform.

Strategic Mission 07-13-2008 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Fischer
The curlin race should have been broadcast on ESPN, Live at 8pm EST with Al Michaels, Stuart Scott, and Durkin on the mic.
There should have been prominent ads for trucks and alcohol on the jockeys, horses and safety rails. We should have been hearing the announcers wax about the versatility of Curlin, the greatness of Red Rocks, and the Broadcast should have been "commercial free" with live wagering on ESPN through the NTRA Call-a-bet/Internet wagering platform.

How about just being on ESPN, not ESPN news, or ESPN a day later on a replay.

dalakhani 07-13-2008 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Strategic Mission
How about just being on ESPN, not ESPN news, or ESPN a day later on a replay.

How many people, besides those that frequent these boards, do you think would watch if it were live on ESPN?

There was nothing of precendence being broadcast yesterday. If Espn thought they could get viewers, they would have shown the race. Unfortunately, the public at large is only really interested in the triple crown these days.

Habersham000 07-13-2008 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
How many people, besides those that frequent these boards, do you think would watch if it were live on ESPN?

There was nothing of precendence being broadcast yesterday. If Espn thought they could get viewers, they would have shown the race. Unfortunately, the public at large is only really interested in the triple crown these days.

During the running of the race yesterday ESPN 2 was showing women's golf...I sure hope horse racing especially with Curlin in a race gets more viewers then women's golf

dalakhani 07-13-2008 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Habersham000
During the running of the race yesterday ESPN 2 was showing women's golf...I sure hope horse racing especially with Curlin in a race gets more viewers then women's golf

Sadly, Habersham, it is actually debatable. I know...scary.

Bobby Fischer 07-13-2008 05:46 PM

i will watch people playing cards or sawing a log or fishing if they put it on tv.

ddthetide 07-13-2008 06:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Fischer
i will watch people playing cards or sawing a log or fishing if they put it on tv.

i draw the line on all 3 but i follow the Tour de France, so i guess that almost as bad.:o

Linny 07-13-2008 07:12 PM

The attendance was dreadful.

Why not use a mass e-mailing to all "rewards" patrons or offer discounted seats or something? Why not have a marketing plan in place ready to crank up if such an opportunity presents itself? I know that the legalities prevented them from knowing for sure if Curlin would race but they had a pretty good idea that IF he was approved, he'd show up.

The box section was like a ghost town yesterday. The only area that was full was the Garden Terrace on the 4th floor but it was almost all "group sales" types, not small collections of friends out for a day at the track. They would have been there Curlin or not.

sumitas 07-13-2008 08:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Fischer
The curlin race should have been broadcast on ESPN, Live at 8pm EST with Al Michaels, Stuart Scott, and Durkin on the mic.
There should have been prominent ads for trucks and alcohol on the jockeys, horses and safety rails. We should have been hearing the announcers wax about the versatility of Curlin, the greatness of Red Rocks, and the Broadcast should have been "commercial free" with live wagering on ESPN through the NTRA Call-a-bet/Internet wagering platform.

All the stops should have been pulled out. Within reason. I can't tell you how many times I had seats for Syracuse football and they changed the kickoff time to accomodate tv.

pgardn 07-13-2008 08:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Habersham000
During the running of the race yesterday ESPN 2 was showing women's golf...I sure hope horse racing especially with Curlin in a race gets more viewers then women's golf

Go down the street to a neighbor and ask who Curlin is...

Then ask about Lauren Ochoa.

My bet is they get Ochoa first.
Or heck some damn poker player.

We have been thru this a million times but
the reinforcement still hurts.

ArlJim78 07-13-2008 08:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pgardn
Go down the street to a neighbor and ask who Curlin is...

Then ask about Lauren Ochoa.

My bet is they get Ochoa first.
Or heck some damn poker player.

We have been thru this a million times but
the reinforcement still hurts.

I have no idea who Lauren Ochoa is.

pgardn 07-13-2008 08:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArlJim78
I have no idea who Lauren Ochoa is.

If you were my neighbor you would know her before Curlin.

herkhorse 07-13-2008 08:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sumitas
All the stops should have been pulled out. Within reason. I can't tell you how many times I had seats for Syracuse football and they changed the kickoff time to accomodate tv.

Syracuse has a football team!?

GBBob 07-13-2008 08:45 PM

In the long run it's irrelevant, but Arlington would have pulled at least 25K if Curlin had run. I really was surprised to see that low a Belmont #..I mean...what would it have been if Curlin didn't run??

rgustafson 07-13-2008 09:15 PM

It should be obvious by now that the only time New York racing fans show up at a track other than Saratoga is if a possible Triple Crown winner is on the line. Breeders Cup, Horse of the year running, ideal weather, who gives a sh**? They couldn't be bothered to get out to the track.

2MinsToPost 07-13-2008 09:21 PM

On another note during the simulcast I thought the music they played when Curlin was coming out for the post parade was cool.

I noticed alot of empty seats behind Curlin man I know I would have been up on the rail trying to get a close look.

herkhorse 07-13-2008 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2MinsToPost
On another note during the simulcast I thought the music they played when Curlin was coming out for the post parade was cool.

I noticed alot of empty seats behind Curlin man I know I would have been up on the rail trying to get a close look.

What did they play, Jesus Christ Superstar, or You Know I Can't Dance?

freddymo 07-14-2008 08:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ArlJim78
I have no idea who Lauren Ochoa is.


She is doable

ateamstupid 07-14-2008 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by herkhorse
What did they play, Jesus Christ Superstar, or You Know I Can't Dance?

"The Champ is Here" by Jadakiss, sampling Will Smith as Muhammad Ali. I thought it was a great touch.

sumitas 07-14-2008 09:51 AM

I'd like to see one more turf effort. Curlin was in position to win at the top of the stretch, no doubt. But the customary kick was not as sharp.

GPK 07-14-2008 09:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pgardn
Go down the street to a neighbor and ask who Curlin is...

Then ask about Lauren Ochoa.

My bet is they get Ochoa first.
Or heck some damn poker player.

We have been thru this a million times but
the reinforcement still hurts.


You live in Texas...near Mexico. Everyone and their brother down there knows who Lorena Ochoa is.

and there is nothing wrong with women's golf on TV:mad:

Linny 07-14-2008 10:07 AM

This past weekend Belmont had 4 former BC winners on the track and fewer asses in the seats than a high school football game.

Sightseek 07-14-2008 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Linny
The attendance was dreadful.

Why not use a mass e-mailing to all "rewards" patrons or offer discounted seats or something? Why not have a marketing plan in place ready to crank up if such an opportunity presents itself? I know that the legalities prevented them from knowing for sure if Curlin would race but they had a pretty good idea that IF he was approved, he'd show up.

The box section was like a ghost town yesterday. The only area that was full was the Garden Terrace on the 4th floor but it was almost all "group sales" types, not small collections of friends out for a day at the track. They would have been there Curlin or not.

If you were on their newsletter email list you would have received an email.

pgardn 07-14-2008 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GPK
You live in Texas...near Mexico. Everyone and their brother down there knows who Lorena Ochoa is.

and there is nothing wrong with women's golf on TV:mad:

Kev if Women's Golf replaces horse racing with 3 BC champs and possibly the best horse in the world, in my bizarre mind, something is very wrong with horse racing. Its not like racing needs 3 straight hours.

pgardn 07-14-2008 10:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GPK
You live in Texas...near Mexico. Everyone and their brother down there knows who Lorena Ochoa is.

and there is nothing wrong with women's golf on TV:mad:

San Antonio watches sports in this order as illustrated by the paper here:

1. Dallas Cowboys (#1 by a mile)
2. San Antonio Spurs
3. Texas Longhorns
4. Texas ATM
5. Any other football.

Its football, football, football, and the Spurs.
Football rules in Texas.

Although San Antonio has about a catrillion golf courses.
Not as many as Phoenix area and other resorts, but too many.

And Nobody really cares that much about Retama Park except truckers
stopping by between San Antonio on the way to Mexico from Dallas and other
places up IH-35. Retama has a great similcast facility so it is a huge luxury for me. But I see it closing the way things are going for racing in general.

MaTH716 07-14-2008 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rgustafson
It should be obvious by now that the only time New York racing fans show up at a track other than Saratoga is if a possible Triple Crown winner is on the line. Breeders Cup, Horse of the year running, ideal weather, who gives a sh**? They couldn't be bothered to get out to the track.

I disagree. OTB has just made it easier to bet away from the track. It doesn't mean that NY fans don't care because they didn't go out to see Curlin.
Belmont is located at the tip of Long Island and is a journey for anyone not from the area. The road that goes out there (Belt Parkway) is a borderline suicide mission. I know that there is a train, but I am assuming most people have to switch several times. I have been to Belmont many times and love it, it is an absolute georgeous venue. But from where I used to live (Staten Island-35 miles away), it was about the same distance to Belmont and Monmouth. Most of the time I went to Monmouth. It just seemed like it was an easier ride. I knew the racing was better at Belmont, but I chose to play it from another track. Now that I live in Jersey, I head down to Monmouth for a couple of races all the time. For most people in NY, it is unrealistic to think that you can just head out to Belmont for a couple of races, you really have to make a day out of it. It is just easier to go to an OTB to bet/watch the one or two races you really want to see. Maybe if it was closer to the city and more accessable, people would go more.
It does bring up the issue what NYRA and Racing can do to get people down to the track for the day.

Holland Hacker 07-14-2008 12:02 PM

Alright I'm one of the Guilty ones who was at Monmouth on Saturday instead of Belmont. Would I have preferred to be at Belmont, Hell yes. But a friend of mine had his annual picnic at Monmouth Park on that day so I was obliged to be at Monmouth. I think my friend would have prefered to be at Belmont as well but since he scheduled his picnic in January I don't think it was really an option especially since he was expecting about 140 people.

I too was shocked that the attendance at Monmouth was > than Belmont.

I live in Western NJ (almost is Pa) and go to NYRA tracks more than I go to Monmouth. Monmouth is just such a pain to get to if you have to take the Garden State Parkway South and fight all of the Shore / Beach traffic. It took about two hours to get to Monmouth and about the same to get home. So for me going to Monmouth is the same kind of committment as it is going to Belmont. Without summer traffic is should only take about an hour. Actually it would probably be quicker to go to Belmont as long as the Yankees aren't play an early afternoon game at the Stadium.

I think you also have to figure into the equation that a lot of people are away on vacation, some of which are down on the Jersey Shore. This plays against Belmont and in favor of Monmouth.

blackthroatedwind 07-14-2008 12:20 PM

Believe it or not, the crowd seemed bigger at Belmont, but maybe that's because I am used to the usual attendance. I disagree with Linny that the box area was a " ghost town " as actually it was probably as busy as it's been any day this meet save the Belmont Stakes. However, I am not suggesting it was packed.

reese 07-14-2008 12:40 PM

Get real here.

As a few knowledgeable posters stated, Belmont is in Long Island, NY and
is SURROUNDED by OTB's in Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, Westchester(Yonkers) and upstate.(Catskill OTB's and Albany OTB's).

The HANDLE at Belmont was 14M+ million Sat. Churchill doesn't even post handle anymore (yes, I know it closed :rolleyes:)

Sure, NYRA would like attendance at the track for the direct handle, but realistically it is easier and cheaper to go to the local OTB or bet from home. Hollywood had attendance of 7800 on Saturday. And there are NO OTB's in CA.:rolleyes: MON doesn't even post total handle.

A trip to Belmont from No. NJ or Westchester is 100-120 miles, RT and $10 in tolls to start. Anyone who has been trapped in LI traffic would NEVER question why a fan would avoid a trip to Belmont. ..a 60 minute drive turns into a 2.5 hr marathon especially on a SATURDAY....even for ppl who live in LI.

Monmouth is at the Jersey Shore...a big summer vacation destination. MON gets the vacation traffic. Not many people are vacationing in Elmont, NY:zz: And Curlin isn't the big fan draw some here seem to believe he should be...:rolleyes:

Stall Mucker 07-14-2008 02:52 PM

Granted, Curlin was not declared until Tuesday or so. But, there were earlier rumblings that he would race in NY barring any further legal problems.
NYRA could have been ready with a better plan. But, I can only place a little blame here.

I made the last minute trip from Saratoga with a car load of peeps who wanted to see a horse we may not get to see in-person again and they didn't like the idea of me, alone at the racetrack un-supervised. ;)

Traffic was not all that bad considering. For us, it was a great time.

Even though Curlin did not win did not ruin the day. This was an experiment. I don't think he ran a bad race.

Attendance was 8000+. Where were more of the fans??

freddymo 07-14-2008 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by reese
Get real here.

As a few knowledgeable posters stated, Belmont is in Long Island, NY and
is SURROUNDED by OTB's in Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, Westchester(Yonkers) and upstate.(Catskill OTB's and Albany OTB's).

The HANDLE at Belmont was 14M+ million Sat. Churchill doesn't even post handle anymore (yes, I know it closed :rolleyes:)

Sure, NYRA would like attendance at the track for the direct handle, but realistically it is easier and cheaper to go to the local OTB or bet from home. Hollywood had attendance of 7800 on Saturday. And there are NO OTB's in CA.:rolleyes: MON doesn't even post total handle.

A trip to Belmont from No. NJ or Westchester is 100-120 miles, RT and $10 in tolls to start. Anyone who has been trapped in LI traffic would NEVER question why a fan would avoid a trip to Belmont. ..a 60 minute drive turns into a 2.5 hr marathon especially on a SATURDAY....even for ppl who live in LI.

Monmouth is at the Jersey Shore...a big summer vacation destination. MON gets the vacation traffic. Not many people are vacationing in Elmont, NY:zz: And Curlin isn't the big fan draw some here seem to believe he should be...:rolleyes:

They should level Belmont build a comfortable grandstand and boxes that hold 10k. One nice small dining room. one super tv room like the new one at Monmouth just bigger and nicer and be done with the 100k white elephant. Yes the BC CUP and Belmont stakes would need temp seating that would not necessarily be under cover but whatever.. There really is no need to keep a building in place that holds 100k when only 2 times a year it reaches 25k or more


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:58 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.