Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   WOW (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=13379)

Suffolk Shippers 05-20-2007 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pmayjr
First Merlinsky,
You're talkin like a bridge-jumper. Sorry you singled SS on top.

I was just sayin SS wasn't good enough TODAY (go back and read it, it's clearly what it says). 2nd, both Nafzger and Borel in interviews after the races said they had no excuses. 3rd, comin around the final turn neither were blocked and neither were extremely wide. They had clean runs going into the stretch (and down the stretch). Whether SS got lazy or not, he got beat TODAY.

I'm not branding one better than the other for the rest of their careers. Hopefully they both go to Belmont, or run later in the summer for many many re-matches to come. Let's hope greedy ownership doesn't send them to the shed before the BC. Just gimme that for both please...


I was at Pimlico and had a nice view from the apron...Street Sense has this race won and as mentioned above, has no excuses but those of his own doing. After the race I wondered if this gazing at the crowd was such an issue, why not throw a shade on his inside eye? Splitting hairs, but something I am curious about.

Give credit to the winner, you almost never see a horse get passed in the stretch (and somewhat convincingly) and then see them surge back to win. SS had a bit to do with it, but Curlin was better on the day.

Suffolk Shippers 05-20-2007 09:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by todko
Tell me that there is no arrogance here:

http://www.nypost.com/seven/05192007...y_kerrison.htm

Yeah, Borel says Curlin, "hasn't stepped up to the plate." And Nafzger says, "it's going to be a fun race."

Curlin stepped up to the plate and I wonder how much fun Nafzger is having today. With their attitude they deserved what they got.

What there is not true? Curlin toyed with greatly inferior competition in some Arkansas stakes and then got bounced around in the Derby. He needed the exprience of some dirt in his face, and some troubles and not just a leisurely stroll to win by 10 lengths.

There is nothing cocky or inaccurate about saying Curlin hadnt stepped up yet. He hadn't. Yesterday he did. Nobody labeled people who knocked Peyton Manning pre 2007 as arrogant when they said he didnt step to the plate and win a Super Bowl, yet.

Also, something tells me Nafzger is having plenty of fun. He's pretty much retired and his last big ticket won the Kentucky Derby and was within a whisker or so of taking the magic ride to Belmont where he could have faced the reality of riding off into the sunset amongst immortals. It's not going to happen, but old Carl will be no worse for the wear I suspect.

declansharbor 05-20-2007 09:28 PM

My first post since the race, and I'm still in awe. Turning for home, I had no doubt in my mind that SS was roping all of them. Once he blew by Curlin, I thought the race was in the bag. BOY, was I wrong. Curlin has made me into a believer. His effort was Spooky Mulder-like, although he wasnt on the front end like SM was in his race. Most horses would have thrown in the towel, not continue to track, then pounce. A bevy of things can be said about Borail's ride to the wire or Pino's premature ga ga goosh, but one thing is for certain, the top three horses in both races have proven they are as good as advertised. As timorous as I was to not hit the trifecta (only played it straight, but big), that all took a backseat to the fact that I knew I was watching something special. Hopefully, a great rivalry will come from these past two weeks.(something horse racing lacks IMO).

Suffolk Shippers 05-20-2007 09:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by declansharbor
My first post since the race, and I'm still in awe. Turning for home, I had no doubt in my mind that SS was roping all of them. Once he blew by Curlin, I thought the race was in the bag. BOY, was I wrong. Curlin has made me into a believer. His effort was Spooky Mulder-like, although he wasnt on the front end like SM was in his race. Most horses would have thrown in the towel, not continue to track, then pounce. A bevy of things can be said about Borail's ride to the wire or Pino's premature ga ga goosh, but one thing is for certain, the top three horses in both races have proven they are as good as advertised. As timorous as I was to not hit the trifecta (only played it straight, but big), that all took a backseat to the fact that I knew I was watching something special. Hopefully, a great rivalry will come from these past two weeks.(something horse racing lacks IMO).

Agreed on the last part...the sport lacks a passioned rivalry. Not sure we will see it here, but seeing these two butt heads across the country a few times this summer and fall would do a wealth of good for the sport...probably more than a Triple Crown champion would have done.

Something where Curlin runs in the Haskell and Street Sense in the Jim Dandy and then they meet at the Travers and then they warm up for the Breeders Cup Classic by running in the JCGC, et al before meeting again in the BCC.
The anticipation that would stand by then just between those two would be great, not to mention others who would run, like Invasor, etc.

Cannon Shell 05-20-2007 09:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by todko
SS got lucky in the Derby. He had a dream trip while Curlin had a nightmare ride.

Street Sense had nothing left.

Curlin didn't hang -- he motored by and tied the Preakness record. A better jock and he would have been the Derby champ too.

He "motored" by?

Cannon Shell 05-20-2007 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by todko
Tell me that there is no arrogance here:

http://www.nypost.com/seven/05192007...y_kerrison.htm

Yeah, Borel says Curlin, "hasn't stepped up to the plate." And Nafzger says, "it's going to be a fun race."

Curlin stepped up to the plate and I wonder how much fun Nafzger is having today. With their attitude they deserved what they got.

Tell me there is no ignorance in pretty much all your posts....










and I'm guessing that you will soon get what you deserve too!!

pgardn 05-20-2007 09:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
He "motored" by?

Motored is the same thing as struggled by apparently ... by a hair.

this race could have so easily gone to Street Sense. So now Curlin is apparently much better.

Cannon Shell 05-20-2007 09:59 PM

Maybe he thinks he would have won by 9 if he had a better jockey

declansharbor 05-20-2007 10:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
Maybe he thinks he would have won by 9 if he had a better jockey

To think that Curlin would have won the Derby with a different jock is preposterous jargon at best.

Cannon Shell 05-20-2007 10:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by declansharbor
To think that Curlin would have won the Derby with a different jock is preposterous jargon at best.

consider the source

declansharbor 05-20-2007 10:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
consider the source

Source considering, he must have been Tony SOprano's payote connect in Vegas to make such outlandish statements. The connections played it perfectly. They know the gem that they have, good for them.

Borel's future with this horse was never in doubt. WIth a few more questionable decisions, do they (nafzger and owners) go elsewhere? My thought would be NO, but who knows in this game. Thoughts?

Cannon Shell 05-20-2007 10:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by declansharbor
Source considering, he must have been Tony SOprano's payote connect in Vegas to make such outlandish statements. The connections played it perfectly. They know the gem that they have, good for them.

Borel's future with this horse was never in doubt. WIth a few more questionable decisions, do they (nafzger and owners) go elsewhere? My thought would be NO, but who knows in this game. Thoughts?

what questionable decisions are you refering too?

sumitas 05-20-2007 10:16 PM

Pino's the jock that needs to go. he moved much too soon in the Preakness.

declansharbor 05-20-2007 10:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
what questionable decisions are you refering too?

After numerous replays, I still haven't seen any " let up" on Borail's part. It seems as if others have a different take on it. I've talked to people who wouldnt know their poo shoot from a hole in the ground, so their opinions were taken with a grain of salt. On the way home from the shore today, sports talk radio had a few "horsemen" who disagreed with Borel's peeking over his shoulder midstretch. I didn't see it as a problem, but given the margin of victory, every move will be heavily scrutinized. In summation, it was not a viewpoint that I shared, but for players and non players alike to have noticed it, I think its mention worthy. Your take?

Cannon Shell 05-20-2007 10:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by declansharbor
After numerous replays, I still haven't seen any " let up" on Borail's part. It seems as if others have a different take on it. I've talked to people who wouldnt know their poo shoot from a hole in the ground, so their opinions were taken with a grain of salt. On the way home from the shore today, sports talk radio had a few "horsemen" who disagreed with Borel's peeking over his shoulder midstretch. I didn't see it as a problem, but given the margin of victory, every move will be heavily scrutinized. In summation, it was not a viewpoint that I shared, but for players and non players alike to have noticed it, I think its mention worthy. Your take?

Not only is it a non issue but there is zero % chance that Calvin will be replaced. The horse got tired in the last 1/16th. It is as simple as that.

The Indomitable DrugS 05-20-2007 10:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
consider the source

The only way I think Curlin could have won the Derby, is if Street Sense had drifted in a little sooner and a little sharper, and dropped Hard Spun or Pino.

Thus, a victory by DQ.

While it's very true that Curlin might have had an 8 length more difficult trip than Street Sense in the Derby....I have very strong doubts another rider would have made too much of a difference.

declansharbor 05-20-2007 10:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
Not only is it a non issue but there is zero % chance that Calvin will be replaced. The horse got tired in the last 1/16th. It is as simple as that.

People try to read too deep into things. Like you said, to make issues where there are none.

If they raced all of the triple crown races at the same track and the Preakness was at CD, does the outcome change if and when Borail takes his horse inside and scrapes paint? Excuse me for the left field question, my buddy that is here with me wants to know ... In other words, is SS a by-product of Churchill Downs "golden rail"??

blackthroatedwind 05-20-2007 10:59 PM

Nobody is actually suggesting that Street Sense likes dirt better at Churchill than he does at Pimlico.....are they?

declansharbor 05-20-2007 11:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackthroatedwind
Nobody is actually suggesting that Street Sense likes dirt better at Churchill than he does at Pimlico.....are they?


No, but while teaching my friend on how to read a program, the novice that he is picked up on SS's CD record and that of other tracks. I just replayed most of his races for him to disprove some statements that he bought into today. We are from Philly so they handfeed us some tidbits on Hard Spun, and this week Pino was talking of a possible advantage with this race being in PIM instead of CD. I tried to steer him from trainer/jock speak to no avail. Larry Jones was hoping for a slight regression from SS because of the track change, and my buddy wanted to know the deal with that..Simple as that.. I didnt want to get too deep into it with him tonite, but I pointed out some things to look for when we head to B-More next week for a trip to the aquarium and PIM. Aren't there suggestions as to the sharpness of the turns being quite different?

bigred06091973 05-20-2007 11:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by King Glorious
So saying he hung today is a bad opinion when most other people on here are saying the same thing and even his own jockey is saying it? U may or may not care about things I have to say on other subjects but what does that have to do with whether this opinion is right or wrong?


Maybe Street Sense has a bad case of hubris. He thinks he has the race won, stops being competitive and lollygags to the finish line. I think it's seasoning is all. He was born in February, was hoping he would be more mature, but I guess some bad habits take more than 9 tries to break.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:40 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.