Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   McKee Blew it! (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4848)

Danzig 09-24-2006 05:02 PM

1 Lava Man 6 6 0 0 $2,470,000
2 Barbaro 5 4 0 0 $2,203,200
3 Bernardini 6 5 0 0 $1,610,480
4 Bluegrass Cat 7 2 4 0 $1,547,500
5 Lawyer Ron 7 5 1 0 $1,340,800
6 Showing Up 7 5 0 1 $1,130,500
7 Fleet Indian 5 5 0 0 $1,113,720
8 Cacique 6 2 3 0 $994,432
9 Invasor 3 3 0 0 $990,000
10 Wait a While 7 4 1 2 $880,807

dalakhani 09-24-2006 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pointg5
He beat a hell alot of horses when he was reeling off his wins, he can only beat who runs against him. Correct? isn't that what you guys are arguing...Let's see what kind of number comes out of this race, I have a feeling it's going to be pretty good....

But can you name ONE that was good? LOL

Rupert Pupkin 09-24-2006 05:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pointg5
Has Bernardini?

Besides, a bunch of tired horses in the Preakness and an injured Barbaro...He got away with slow fractions in the Jim Dandy and beat a 3 legged Blue Grass Cat in the Travers...

I agree with you. I don't think that Lawyer Ron is nearly as good as Bernardini but I hate it when people ask who a horse has beaten. If a person has any scouting ability at all, they can tell whether a horse is good regardless of who he's beaten.

Bernardini hasn't beaten any great horses on their best day. Sweetnorthernsaint didn't run anything close to his best in the Preakness. Brother Derek didn't fire in the Preakness. Bernardini beat nobody in his first race this summer. His last race is the only race where you could say he beat a pretty good horse in Bluegrass Cat. BGC may not have run his best that day but I think he ran close to his best.

By the way, Lawyer Ron kept beating that grey horse over and over again. That grey horse ran 3rd in the Ky Derby.

LR is a very good horse. He's not nealy as good as Bernardini but neither is anyone else. LR is in the top handful of best 3 year olds.

Pointg5 09-24-2006 05:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaHoss9698
I don't really get what you are asking but the point is, Lawyer Ron fans have been making excuses for two days now. You attempted to try and compare he and Bernardini and it was a bad comparison.

If you can't understand that you are arguing the same thing, by saying that LR beat no one, but Bernardini has beat all of the ones they put in the gate, how is that not contradicting yourself...I guess you are too assinine to figure it out...

dalakhani 09-24-2006 05:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig188
1 Lava Man 6 6 0 0 $2,470,000
2 Barbaro 5 4 0 0 $2,203,200
3 Bernardini 6 5 0 0 $1,610,480
4 Bluegrass Cat 7 2 4 0 $1,547,500
5 Lawyer Ron 7 5 1 0 $1,340,800
6 Showing Up 7 5 0 1 $1,130,500
7 Fleet Indian 5 5 0 0 $1,113,720
8 Cacique 6 2 3 0 $994,432
9 Invasor 3 3 0 0 $990,000
10 Wait a While 7 4 1 2 $880,807

Its nice to be in those three year old restricted races and have all of the races you run in come up light. A horse can win a lot of money.

The connections should be applauded for a well run campaign. Winning 1.3 and not beating good horses is a hell of an accomplishment.

dalakhani 09-24-2006 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rupert Pupkin
I agree with you. I don't think that Lawyer Ron is nearly as good as Bernardini but I hate it when people ask who a horse has beaten. If a person has any scouting ability at all, they can tell whether a horse is good regardless of who he's beaten.

Bernardini hasn't beaten any great horses on their best day. Sweetnorthernsaint didn't run anything close to his best in the Preakness. Brother Derek didn't fire in the Preakness. Bernardini beat nobody in his first race this summer. His last race is the only race where you could say he beat a pretty good horse in Bluegrass Cat. BGC may not have run his best that day but I think he ran close to his best.

By the way, Lawyer Ron kept beating that grey horse over and over again. That grey horse ran 3rd in the Ky Derby.

LR is a very good horse. He's not nealy as good as Bernardini but neither is anyone else. LR is in the top handful of best 3 year olds.

Isnt that "grey horse" still eligible for nx2 competition?

kentuckyrosesinmay 09-24-2006 05:06 PM

I'm a Lawyer Ron fan and I'm not making excuses although it is obvious that the horse could have possibly won the race if he wasn't so rank early own.

Lawyer Ron is not as good as Bernardini...no way.

However, Lawyer Ron is definitely in the top tier of the 3 yos. He is 5th on the earnings list of all horses of this year. I really like the colt. If spotted right, this horse will go on to win many more stakes races. He probably could have beat SC yesterday if he would have settled. That WAS NOT his best performance as he was very rank early. I really think that LR is improving too, at least, since this spring.

I think he stands a shot to win races such as the Cigar Mile if prepared properly. However, he should not be put in races such as the BC Classic. At this point, I really think that he has distance limitations as I have probably said many times throughout this thread...

dalakhani 09-24-2006 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kentuckyrosesinmay
I'm a Lawyer Ron fan and I'm not making excuses although it is obvious that the horse could have possibly won the race if he wasn't so rank early own.

Lawyer Ron is not as good as Bernardini...no way.

However, Lawyer Ron is definitely in the top tier of the 3 yos. He is 5th on the earnings list of all horses of this year. I really like the colt. If spotted right, this horse will go on to win many more stakes races. He probably could have beat SC yesterday if he would have settled. That WAS NOT his best performance as he was very rank early. I really think that LR is improving too, at least, since this spring.

I think he stands a shot to win races such as the Cigar Mile if prepared properly. However, he should not be put in races such as the BC Classic. At this point, I really think that he has distance limitations as I have probably said many times throughout this post...

I'll tell you what Roses, we can set up our own future book right here and i will give you 50-1 right now if you want to take Lawyer Ron in the cigar.

kentuckyrosesinmay 09-24-2006 05:10 PM

I don't know who is in the race and I don't know if he will go to that race or not. Plus, I don't like future bets. However, if he does go, I will tell everyone on this board what I think of his chances. Because the top horses in the country normally run in the BC Classic, it is usually the second tier GI horses going in the Cigar Mile. I think that LR is talented enough to be a second tier GI horse at that distance.

Danzig 09-24-2006 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaHoss9698
This really proves nothing though because the purses are so high for the 3 year olds stakes at Oaklawn. Purse value does not necessarily indicate talent in the race. Lawyer Ron was by far the most talented horse to come out of Oaklawn this year, but the second was Steppenwolfer, who, sorry is a second tier 3 year old. He did suck up for third in the Derby, but he was beat how many?

thing is, just like every other year, anyone can come to arkansas. purses are high everywhere for 3 yo's in the spring, the florida derby also offers 1 million. blue grass stakes with 750k...but no sinister minister in the top ten.

all i know is, if lawyer ron is so bad, than maybe oxley and ward better reconsider going to the bcc with strong contender...since he's only managed to beat a horse yesterday who evidently has only beaten bad horses. you'd think a bunch of other bad-horse-beaters would come to ark for the easy money as well...
i hope some day i own a rotten mule like lawyer ron, i'll be laughing all the way to the bank.

Rupert Pupkin 09-24-2006 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
Its nice to be in those three year old restricted races and have all of the races you run in come up light. A horse can win a lot of money.

The connections should be applauded for a well run campaign. Winning 1.3 and not beating good horses is a hell of an accomplishment.

That's ridiculous. I could say the same thing about practically every good 3 year old. Who did Barbaro ever beat before the Derby?

Giacomo, on the other hand, beat some good horses in the Ky Derby. Does that prove that Gicaomo is a great horse? Not al all. He beat some great horses in the Derby but none of those horses ran their best that day. It's not who you beat. It's how you do it. You'd never make it as a bloodstock agent if you were constantly asking who a horse beat. Yuo won't be very successful as a bettor either. If you can't pick out a good horse until he beats a great horse in a fast time, you'll end up betting on nothing but 3-5 shots.

Danzig 09-24-2006 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaHoss9698
No no, my point was after the Saratoga races everyone was questioning the competition that Bernardini was facing. Well by that same logic who has Lawyer Ron faced? For 2 days a lot are trying to blame the jock, when in fact Lawyer Ron should have won yesterday, rank or not. I think Lawyer Ron is a horse that is talented no doubt, by not in the same league as Bernardini, Discreet Cat, Bluegrass Cat, Barbaro, or Showing Up.

and i agree completely with that! they can't all be top tier.
like i said, different folks will always question what horses beat. thing is, the horses have no control at all over who they face. all they can do is try their best. thank goodness for the horses mental well being, they can't read!! they'd all be in therapy!!

Rupert Pupkin 09-24-2006 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dalakhani
Isnt that "grey horse" still eligible for nx2 competition?

Does that mean he has to give back the money he's won?

Pointg5 09-24-2006 05:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaHoss9698
No no, my point was after the Saratoga races everyone was questioning the competition that Bernardini was facing. Well by that same logic who has Lawyer Ron faced? For 2 days a lot are trying to blame the jock, when in fact Lawyer Ron should have won yesterday, rank or not. I think Lawyer Ron is a horse that is talented no doubt, by not in the same league as Bernardini, Discreet Cat, Bluegrass Cat, Barbaro, or Showing Up.

I never once blamed the jock, I don't think it was his fault, maybe he should have let him run, but who knows if that would have made a difference...I said the whole thing is on LR...He should have won yesterday, but he didn't, no excuses from me, he went too fast too early...

SC ran a huge Sheet # at Belmont, he's a much better horse than I thought, for LR to run like he did against him really impressed me...I am tired of this conversation and I am out...I should be happy, the Bengals won today...I am sorry Dahoss for using the F bomb on you, that was uncalled for, but I didn't like the tone you were using with me...I edited the post and pm'd Kasept to tell him what I did, I feel bad for doing that...It's just a message board and I shouldn't get so heated...

Danzig 09-24-2006 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaHoss9698
Okay first of all Lawyer Ron is of course better than SM, no doubt. Do you think Stong Contender has a shot in the Classic, really? He was trounced by Bluegrass Cat, who in turn was trounced by Bernardini, I know he was hurt. I'm not saying Lawyer Ron is a mule he is a very talented horse, but can you name me 1 horse to come out of the Oaklawn 3 year old preps to win a graded stakes race?

high cotton-graded winner and graded placed since the ark derby.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.