Would not have gone with that winner in sporting.

That was a really nice ESS - survived the cut but didn't get a piece of the group. It's easy to arm chair judge, but we're not the one in the ring getting up close and personal with those dogs.

That cocker has been heavily campaigned and advertised this past year. One of the favorites to win BIS.

Puhleeze. I could judge this in my sleep

Im waiting for the Terrier Group. I have a Staffordshire Terrier and im hoping he is sleeping but watches to hopefully learn something. LMAO. I still love my dog no matter what. He has gone through alot before he became my dog.

Are you a judge? Have you ever judged? It's a whole lot different judging outside the ring than in. I don't necessarily agree with the Sporting Group Judge's opinion, but it is Westminster - there's a lot of paybacks and politics going on.

So true. Now go Alaskan Malamute!:tro:

Forget the malamute. Doesn't have much reach in the front end.:o

The boxer is another one that was heavily campaigned and advertised last year. Wouldn't be surprised to see her get the group.

That was a pretty nice "pile" that Judge Collier pulled out in the Working Group. I also liked the Siberian. The Doberman looked gorgeous on the stack, but the handler was handicapped by a bit too much weight and didn't move the dog to its full potential. Portuguese going Group I? Maybe she's looking for a trip to the White House.:D

Where did the St. Bernard handler get that jacket she was wearing. How embarrassing to be captured on national tv with a jacket 2 to 3 sizes too small and not covering up an abundance of "speed bumps."
Meow, meow! Yeah, I know - it's petty, but I can't help but comment.

Perhaps it was his markings, but that Smooth Fox Terrier caught my eye. He looked like Phantom of the Opera. Really surprised the Sealyham didn't get a piece of that group - what a resume.

I think another Smooth Fox could go BIS. Please, please, don't let that dustmop Peke win - please.

I like the Bearded Collie but I'm thinking it's between the cocker and the Peke.

I am going with the Scottish Deer hound to bring it home.

Black Cocker Spaniel to come in second.

Smooth Fox Terrier in 3rd.

The Peke is adorable though. :)

I think the host just jizzed his pants.

I like this judge. He actually judged the dogs instead of playing politics.

(Less talking would be nice though)

Didn't see this but good call.

I wouldn't have figured an Italian judge to go for a hound - especially a Scottish Deerhound. There are no 2nd and 3rd place for Best In Show.

My pick would have been the Smooth Fox Terrier. After that, I liked the Beardie, the Cocker, the Deerhound, the Shar Pei, the Portie, and the Peke.

i've always disliked poodles, but that peke is a trainwreck. who ever thought a dog should look like that? ugh

Standard Poodles are a neat breed - nothing sissy about them and scary smart.

For the reason you give is precisely the reason I do not like Peke's. Man has interfered so much in developing this breed that they're basically good for nothing.

i don't like poofy dogs. give me a german shepherd, weimeraner, husky, or any working dog or terrier any day. a peke, or most any other toy-you can have it.
i was pulling for the fox terrier, but considering the age and history of a scottish deerhound, i was happy that one won. and thank goodness, not a poodle in the mix. some years, a couple of them invade the last round.

Same here. I fully expected to see the Black Cocker win, but was pulling for (what I thought was the) unlikely Scottish Deerhound. I can't remember the last time that the dog I was hoping to see win BIS actually did win it. Nice comments by the judge afterward.

Regarding the Black Cocker, was it just me or did the handler never seem quite prepared to move her dog when asked?

It does take longer for certain breeds to get ready to move because the handler removes the collar and leash as they are standing for examination and then has to put it back on to get ready to move. Did you notice how long it took for the Skye Terrier handler to move the dog because he was brushing all the mussed hair back into place?

I always laugh because they all shake when they get off the table and mess up their "do" :)

I am sure it irritates the handlers of the long haired one to no end.

It was good to see a real dog win and not the freaking Pekingese. That's not even a dog, it's some kind of overgrown cat/rat hybrid.

HOUND GROUP PLACEMENTS
Scottish Deerhound who went on to Best in Show
Beagle 15"
Norwegian Elkhound
PBGV

TOY GROUP PLACEMENTS
Pekingese
Affenpinscher
Pug
Papillon

NON SPORTING GROUP PLACEMENTS
Chinese Shar-Pei
Bichon Frises
Lhasa Apso
Keeshond

HERDING GROUP PLACEMENTS
Bearded Collie
Belgian Tervuren
Border Collie
Pembroke Welsh Corgi

SPORTING GROUP PLACEMENTS
Cocker Spaniel - Black
Irish Setter
Wirehaired Pointing Griffon
Irish Water Spaniel

WORKING GROUP PLACEMENTS
Portuguese Water Spaniel
Boxer
Kuvasz
Samoyed

TERRIER GROUP PLACEMENTS
Smooth Fox Terrier
Norfolk Terrier
Skye Terrier
West Highland White Terrier

You can read more about these dogs and see pictures of them here -

http://www.westminsterkennelclub.org...oup/index.html

The Dobe got robbed, not even included in the group's 4? I don't care how fat the handler was, that was nonsense. Dog was perfect.

I tend to agree with you as to the static balance of the Dobe, but movement counts a lot especially for a breed like Dobes. When I saw how she moved the dog, I figured she was sunk. The breed rings are teeny tiny at Westminster, and they don't get to move the dogs well there. But the group ring is huge and a handler has to take full advantage - not mincing around the ring expecting the dog to look its best. Gaiting shouldn't be about how fast one can run - just gaiting the dog fast enough to show its reach and drive capability and the strength of the topline. The lady handler on the Dobe was not able to do that. But, maybe, just maybe, the judge didn't like the dog for other reasons.

Some other info which some of you might find interesting.

Popularity list of breeds according to AKC registrations -

http://www.akc.org/reg/dogreg_stats.cfm

Nice to see Dobes are getting more popular, great dogs. We actually got ours from a shelter here and despite being fixed and having his ears and tail I have been told by breeders that he "could've really been something" we think he is anyway.

Dobermans have a LOT of health problem - biggest one is heart problems. Lots of young dogs dying in this breed. The more popular a dog becomes, the more breeding is done to meet the demand. Lots of room there for a decrease in discriminate breeding and just breeding anything to anything to producer a litter of puppies to sell.

Dobes are a wonderful breed. I hope yours lives a long and healthy life. But anyone in the market to buy one should do a lot of shopping around making certain that the breeder diligently screens for health defects.

This is just basic practice when shopping for any breed. Stay away from pet shops. If you want a specific breed and don't necessary want a puppy, check out rescue dogs for that breed at the parent club's web-site. If you're not in the market for a specific breed, visit your local shelter. It's a tough thing to do, however. My husband and I volunteered at a local shelter, and I came home every night in tears knowing full well that half of those dogs would never find a home.

Oh shut up.

Make me!

My wife volunteers for a no kill shelter, that can be sad.

I had some Dalmatians from a rescue shelter years ago. One had to be put asleep because of a stomach issue and it was also deaf. Another one had three legs and had to put asleep because of a stroke and seizure issues. Im thinking he had a seizure that may of lead to a stroke. Now I have a dog that im thinking is a Staffordshire Terrier but the vet where I got it from says it was a pit.

soooo glad a little carpet cra pper didn't win

i always :rolleyes: when the handler pulls out the damn brush to fix the dogs hair before moving the dog. gimme a break. get your mutt and get out of the way!

Help me out here Vet says Pit im thinking he has some terrier in him:

the pic is worsae than mine

umm. looks like a small pit eating kitty

They both actually get along great.

Pretty good explanation of what a Pit is -

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pit_bull