| RolloTomasi |
06-02-2008 05:38 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by King Glorious
I'm not sure how that addresses the fact that both have only run five times and have further room for improvement.
|
It doesn't, but it does address a significant difference between BB and Zenyatta, the latter whom you consider "every bit as impressive" as the former. I took the basis of your post to be a comparison between those two horses as far as facing each other in the BC Classic goes.
Maybe I was mistaken and it was just meant to let everyone know that Zenyatta had only run 5 times. Because no one but you had realized this.
And just to stir the pot a little more, what raises more questions as far as physical condition and susceptibility to injury goes, a 3yo with only 5 career starts or a 4yo (that happens to be about 17 hands) with only 5 career starts?
Quote:
In fact, I'd even say that means that Zenyatta has more room since we already know what BB can do at 10f but haven't seen Zenyatta try it yet.
|
So basically, you are trying to sugar-coat the fact that Zenyatta has more question marks on paper than Big Brown?
Quote:
As weak as you may think Ginger Punch is, do you think any of the 3yo's that Big Brown have faced this year are better than her?
|
Wasn't the point I was trying to make. The point was that the form Ginger Punch showed at Oaklawn wasn't the form that garnered her the 2007 Eclipse. Was Gayego's Arkansas Derby a stronger performance than Ginger Punch's 3rd in the Apple Blossom? Yes. Does that somehow mean that BB, who crushed Gayego unceremoniously in his last two, is better than Zenyatta? No. |
