Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   Sports Bar & Grill (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Bama's offer to Saban (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=7565)

oracle80 12-08-2006 09:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.
well, I guess I didn't realize there were so many experts
on Alabama Football here besides myself and DD
Alabama has done nothing wrong
They simply are after the best coach they can find
as would all the top programs be in a head coaching search
we went after guy who is is highly regarded in the coaching community
and he kind of left us at the altar and changed his mind
but how does that give the media & fans of other programs
the right to rip our program for trying to make a good hire?
we gave the guy an excellent opportunity~
more than doubling his current salary, top-notch facilities,
and a chance to compete at college football's highest level
how are we wrong in doing this? because he said no?
I say we keep aiming high, if not higher
or at least higher in the quality of the individual


I think spending more than one week or so would be a good start,
Maybe compiling a good list, and making quiet inquiries rather than put coaches still coaching on the spot now before bowl games.
Its half assed dude, half assed and half baked.
The notion that guys still coaching pro and college teams are just gonna drop what they are doing and come running because its bama.
I'm saying, they are going about this the wrong way, and I think by the results they are having thats its obvious.

ddthetide 12-08-2006 09:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oracle80
I think spending more than one week or so would be a good start,
Maybe compiling a good list, and making quiet inquiries rather than put coaches still coaching on the spot now before bowl games.
Its half assed dude, half assed and half baked.
The notion that guys still coaching pro and college teams are just gonna drop what they are doing and come running because its bama.
I'm saying, they are going about this the wrong way, and I think by the results they are having thats its obvious.

for your info spurrier, saban, grobe contacted Bama behind the scenes.
RR was highly recommended to Bama by Homer Smith. if Homer Smith tells you to go get someone then i think you take that recommendation.

BellamyRd. 12-08-2006 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ddthetide
for your info spurrier, saban, grobe contacted Bama behind the scenes.
RR was highly recommended to Bama by Homer Smith. if Homer Smith tells you to go get someone then i think you take that recommendation.

their MO is to belittle the Tide and not to try and understand anything
and then make tired old racist comments which do not ring true anymore
if the Tide job isn't so important, why are we talking about it
why is it a top national sports media story over other openings:Miami, NC State, BC, etc.? and upcoming bowl games?
the have-nots will always be intimidated by the haves, and talk about
what they are doing

dr. fager 12-08-2006 10:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.
their MO is to belittle the Tide and not to try and understand anything
and then make tired old racist comments which do not ring true anymore
if the Tide job isn't so important, why are we talking about it
why is it a top national sports media story over other openings:Miami, NC State, BC, etc.? and upcoming bowl games?
the have-nots will always be intimidated by the haves, and talk about
what they are doing


You had me until you said NC State and BC....


once a coach always a coach.

oracle80 12-09-2006 05:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.
their MO is to belittle the Tide and not to try and understand anything
and then make tired old racist comments which do not ring true anymore
if the Tide job isn't so important, why are we talking about it
why is it a top national sports media story over other openings:Miami, NC State, BC, etc.? and upcoming bowl games?
the have-nots will always be intimidated by the haves, and talk about
what they are doing

Miami chose poorly in my opinion, I think they screwed up as well.
Bama's job is certainly more important than NC St and BC!!!!!!
I don't think you get what I'm saying here, I never said it wasn't still a prestigious job, I just said it wasn't at the VERY top.
I wonder why a guy named Rodriguez didn't wanna go there?:rolleyes: :D

Danzig 12-09-2006 06:26 AM

i have a hard time believing saban would be interested. had he wanted to be in college bowl, he'd have stayed at lsu. he's turning miami around, they're showing good signs these days.
alabama is one of the better programs in the sec. no doubt whoever they get will be proud to be there.

ddthetide 12-09-2006 06:52 AM

saban's agaent contacted Bama before the dolphins started to win and it looked like saban would lose his job.

i guess Bama moves on to Grobe of wake, Paul Johnson of Navy, Kraigthrope of Tulsa and MAYBE Stoops at Oklahoma.

Grobe doesn't excite me. i'd love Johnson he'd do a great job and has 2 NC already. Kraigthrope, i don't know enough about and Stoops would scare me because the ncaa is snooping around oklahoma now for the off field stuff that cost him his qb at the start of the season.

uscrules 12-09-2006 07:31 AM

i have been asked to interview for the job at Alabama. Still weighing my options. it will have to wait for the end of our season here in KC. Home game this weekend but a tough Raven team to deal with. Practices were very good this week so we're expecting a big game tomorrow. Word.

oracle80 12-09-2006 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uscrules
i have been asked to interview for the job at Alabama. Still weighing my options. it will have to wait for the end of our season here in KC. Home game this weekend but a tough Raven team to deal with. Practices were very good this week so we're expecting a big game tomorrow. Word.

Yeah ok sure, and I've been asked by President Bush to interview to be the new terror czar.

oracle80 12-09-2006 08:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ddthetide
saban's agaent contacted Bama before the dolphins started to win and it looked like saban would lose his job.

i guess Bama moves on to Grobe of wake, Paul Johnson of Navy, Kraigthrope of Tulsa and MAYBE Stoops at Oklahoma.

Grobe doesn't excite me. i'd love Johnson he'd do a great job and has 2 NC already. Kraigthrope, i don't know enough about and Stoops would scare me because the ncaa is snooping around oklahoma now for the off field stuff that cost him his qb at the start of the season.


DDtide,
I don't get it. With the success of Carroll, and with Weis grabbing every top recruit in the country, as well as the success that Butch davis had at Miami, etc. I think that its obvious that pro guys have a big edge in college.
You sit down in a kids living room and they all wanna play in the NFL. They see Weis rings, or talk a guy who like carroll who tells him he has all the pro contacts, and they wanna come and chase the dream thinking the Coach has an edge to get them there.
WHy chase all these college coaches like RR, etc. when there are some good asst coaches in the NFL who are damn smart and would love the opportunity?
Thats my point. Guys like RR aren't stupid, they realize they only have one more big move left in them, and they are gonna save it for their dream job.
I truly believe that Bowden and Paterno are just about done, and guys like RR and Rutgers guy are gonna lay in waiting for those jobs. Its just so much easier to recruit at schools like that than it is at Bama.
Saban probably would have come back to college, but his recent wins had him reasess. Its gotta be frustrating to come to a team expecting Ricky Williams and losing him, then signing Culpepper and having him be a total bust. But hes got the cash, and figures college jobs will always be there.
Pro coaches have a real grind(and assts) the camps start in July, and the season stretches until at LEAST early January.
College coaching is a bit easier timewise, and many find working with kids again after workiing with spoiled millionaires who don't listen, to be very rewarding.

Danzig 12-09-2006 08:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oracle80
Yeah ok sure, and I've been asked by President Bush to interview to be the new terror czar.

and i'm packing my bags as i'm the new ambassador to the court of st. james. having tea with the queen next thursday. have to go practice my curtsy.

Danzig 12-09-2006 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oracle80
DDtide,
I don't get it. With the success of Carroll, and with Weis grabbing every top recruit in the country, as well as the success that Butch davis had at Miami, etc. I think that its obvious that pro guys have a big edge in college.
You sit down in a kids living room and they all wanna play in the NFL. They see Weis rings, or talk a guy who like carroll who tells him he has all the pro contacts, and they wanna come and chase the dream thinking the Coach has an edge to get them there.
WHy chase all these college coaches like RR, etc. when there are some good asst coaches in the NFL who are damn smart and would love the opportunity?
Thats my point. Guys like RR aren't stupid, they realize they only have one more big move left in them, and they are gonna save it for their dream job.
I truly believe that Bowden and Paterno are just about done, and guys like RR and Rutgers guy are gonna lay in waiting for those jobs. Its just so much easier to recruit at schools like that than it is at Bama.
Saban probably would have come back to college, but his recent wins had him reasess. Its gotta be frustrating to come to a team expecting Ricky Williams and losing him, then signing Culpepper and having him be a total bust. But hes got the cash, and figures college jobs will always be there.
Pro coaches have a real grind(and assts) the camps start in July, and the season stretches until at LEAST early January.
College coaching is a bit easier timewise, and many find working with kids again after workiing with spoiled millionaires who don't listen, to be very rewarding.

nick should have stayed at lsu. but that's water under the bridge. he's had some things go wrong down there, but i think he can put it all together. we shall see.

and i agree that paterno and bowden are about ready to go. how could they not be? a changing of the guard at psu/fsu. all the respect in the world for joe paterno, not so much from me for bobby bowden.

BellamyRd. 12-09-2006 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oracle80
Miami chose poorly in my opinion, I think they screwed up as well.
Bama's job is certainly more important than NC St and BC!!!!!!
I don't think you get what I'm saying here, I never said it wasn't still a prestigious job, I just said it wasn't at the VERY top.
I wonder why a guy named Rodriguez didn't wanna go there?:rolleyes: :D

the national media did not take pot-shots at Miami when Schiano, a coach at Rutgers (with Miami ties) turned them down like they did when Coach Rod turned Bama down...it's like they have an agenda against us. Also, Miami, with a higher hispanic population wanted Coach Rod as well, but he only listened to us. I agree they should get an NFL guy as the remaining "hot" college guys don't impress me either. But that would mean waiting about 4-5 weeks at the very least, while the solid recruiting class Shula lined up is dropping by the hour without a head coach in place.

Coach Pants 12-09-2006 09:13 AM

Paul Bryant Jr. has to give up control and Mal needs to retire. This is a failure of epic proportions on their part. It's so bad we'll probably be reduced to offering Rush Propst the job and he'll decline and stay with Hoover.

oracle80 12-09-2006 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.
the national media did not take pot-shots at Miami when Schiano, a coach at Rutgers (with Miami ties) turned them down like they did when Coach Rod turned Bama down...it's like they have an agenda against us. Also, Miami, with a higher hispanic population wanted Coach Rod as well, but he only listened to us. I agree they should get an NFL guy as the remaining "hot" college guys don't impress me either. But that would mean waiting about 4-5 weeks at the very least, while the solid recruiting class Shula lined up is dropping by the hour without a head coach in place.

Dude, the guy at Rutgers has pulled off the greatest coaching miracle I ever saw. EVER! he turned around and made a winner into a team that noone in the world would have felt possible.
His next move is to a dream job, and Miami aint no dream job.
That guy wants Penn St, it aint no secret. At some point Joe Pa will do whats right and make sure when he steps down that they will get the guy they need. Hes the guy. He can stay in the east and move to the Big Ten.
He wasn't going to Miami and everyone knew it.
Logistics do play a role in a job a guy takes, and Alabama isn't a big media market. You'll end up getting the right guy, it just won't be the guys you initially wanted.
Tom Coughlin may be available soon, God I hope so, and hes a better college coach than a pro coach. Hes aged about 30 years the last few years in NY, and I bet he'd like a job like that. he'd be on my list if I were Bama.

Coach Pants 12-09-2006 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oracle80
Tom Coughlin may be available soon, God I hope so, and hes a better college coach than a pro coach. Hes aged about 30 years the last few years in NY, and I bet he'd like a job like that. he'd be on my list if I were Bama.

You're kidding right?

paisjpq 12-09-2006 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig188
and i'm packing my bags as i'm the new ambassador to the court of st. james. having tea with the queen next thursday. have to go practice my curtsy.

they have asked me to host the ocsars this year...still on the fence about it though...

uscrules 12-09-2006 09:32 AM

tom coughlin couldnt coach a high school team let alone a team with the storied history like Alabama. not sure if i will pursue this offer, may take a job back in Cali under Coach Pete. my phone has been ringing off the hook and it looks like a perfect fit. god i miss surfing.

BellamyRd. 12-09-2006 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uscrules
tom coughlin couldnt coach a high school team let alone a team with the storied history like Alabama. not sure if i will pursue this offer, may take a job back in Cali under Coach Pete. my phone has been ringing off the hook and it looks like a perfect fit. god i miss surfing.

dude, what is that house in your avatar?

uscrules 12-09-2006 09:37 AM

its my house i just bought 2 months ago.
off to the weight room now. you have a good day Bama fan.

BellamyRd. 12-09-2006 09:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uscrules
its my house i just bought 2 months ago.
off to the weight room now. you have a good day Bama fan.

LOL, who puts their house as their avatar? I like you kid, you're a little cooky, stick around.

BellamyRd. 12-09-2006 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pillow Pants
Paul Bryant Jr. has to give up control and Mal needs to retire. This is a failure of epic proportions on their part. It's so bad we'll probably be reduced to offering Rush Propst the job and he'll decline and stay with Hoover.

watched Clerks 2 last night and LMAO
yeah, the problem is these old school guys like Mal and Paul Jr. are playing in a whole new ball game~ and that's why they brought in Chuck Neinas, who
should be fired immediately BTW
they need a good PR firm, and to sue ESPN & the Miami Herald for reporting false and damaging information
I hope Pratville whips Hoover
if it's Probst, I'm walking downtown and leaping off one of the bridges

Samarta 12-09-2006 10:12 AM

Rich Rodriguez never intended on leaving WVU. Alabama is an attractive job for someone that is trying to make a name for themselves and granted there is quite a storied past. But if the people there think they can just throw out the ole Roll Tide and people are going to jump, they are sadly mistaken. There is no reason at all for any of the people mentioned as potential candidates to take this job. All they need to do is look at the attrition rate over the last 7 years to understand that there is absolutely no loyalty when it comes to being the head football coach there. Maybe if you pull off 11/1 or so in you first year, but that's about it. There was mention that RR broke a gentlemen's agreement earlier in this thread. I find that almost laughable. I wonder how many agreements were broken by the boosters and administrators when they sat down over the last 7 years and decided that the coach at the time wasn't the second coming afterall.

Coach Pants 12-09-2006 10:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.
watched Clerks 2 last night and LMAO
yeah, the problem is these old school guys like Mal and Paul Jr. are playing in a whole new ball game~ and that's why they brought in Chuck Neinas, who
should be fired immediately BTW
they need a good PR firm, and to sue ESPN & the Miami Herald for reporting false and damaging information
I hope Pratville whips Hoover
if it's Probst, I'm walking downtown and leaping off one of the bridges

:P

We should make ESPN happy and hire a black coach. Ken Norton Jr. would be an excellent hire. Sure he lacks experience but he's done an excellent job as linebackers coach at USC. I imagine he could be a heck of a recruiter considering the Super Bowl rings he could flaunt.

ddthetide 12-09-2006 11:53 AM

ozzie newsome is "supposed" to be feeling out the nfl for coaches. everyone figures ozzie as the next AD at Bama when Coach Moore finally retires. i would think that after this Coach Moore will be ready to get out.
between ozzie and the Bama nfl alums seems like someone else would ahve popped up by now. Mike Sherman has thrown his hat in the ring publicly, not sure how i feel about that one.

Bama's not that hard to recruit for. Bama owns the state whether the barners like it or not. all they need is the couple kids from GA, TX, FLA, La. to finish out the rooster. Bama will sell it's self. the kids are instant "rock stars" the first visit to campus the they are asked for the autograph. the facilites are FIRST class. they are nfl facilites not as good as Bama's.

what i see as the problem is coaches don't want to have to coach in the SEC. face the facts week in and week out is a street brawl. if you can win 10 games every couple years or make arun at the NC every couples years you can be KING at Bama. it can bedone and fairly quick..... Bama is close to being Back, with the right coach to lead the way.

Danzig 12-09-2006 01:15 PM

i think a lot of coaches show interest in a supposed better situation just to get a bigger offer at home. hell, who wants to pack and move? not me. spurrier had a rumor started that he might be interested in florida, not sure he was the one who started it of course.... but he quickly quashed it and ended up 500k richer a year, and guaranteed salary thru '12.
wvu has been higher up in the last few years than 'bama, he wouldn't necessarily be improving his situation--while the stakes would be much higher than where he is now, much like spurrier said about the 'canes.

BellamyRd. 12-09-2006 01:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig188
i think a lot of coaches show interest in a supposed better situation just to get a bigger offer at home. hell, who wants to pack and move? not me. spurrier had a rumor started that he might be interested in florida, not sure he was the one who started it of course.... but he quickly quashed it and ended up 500k richer a year, and guaranteed salary thru '12.
wvu has been higher up in the last few years than 'bama, he wouldn't necessarily be improving his situation--while the stakes would be much higher than where he is now, much like spurrier said about the 'canes.

omg, WE got Spurrier that raise NOT UF, how the hell would he get that job back when their coach has them in the title game?
WV plays in the Big East! all 9 SEC bowl teams could have finished 10-2
with WV's schedule

Danzig 12-09-2006 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BellamyRd.
omg, WE got Spurrier that raise NOT UF, how the hell would he get that job back when their coach has them in the title game?
WV plays in the Big East! all 9 SEC bowl teams could have finished 10-2
with WV's schedule

oops. put florida, it was miami that was rumored to be interested. didn't see anything about bama wanting him.

Danzig 12-09-2006 01:26 PM

as for where alabama and wv play, has nothing to do with which would be 'better'. wvu has been in contention the last few years. bama wants to be, and has quite a storied history. BUT right now they are viewed as being very high risk, and possibly not high return. there is no patience down there for a coach to come in, recruit and build a program. especially considering sanctions they've had, which hurt recruitment. the merry go round of coaches here the last few years has hurt recruitment as well. i think shula did pretty well considering everything he took on. and now they have a huge question mark again.
as for bama owing recruits in alabama, i think auburn might disagree.

Cajungator26 12-09-2006 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig188
nick should have stayed at lsu. but that's water under the bridge. he's had some things go wrong down there, but i think he can put it all together. we shall see.

and i agree that paterno and bowden are about ready to go. how could they not be? a changing of the guard at psu/fsu. all the respect in the world for joe paterno, not so much from me for bobby bowden.

FSU will be grooming Jimbo Fisher before it's all said and done, IMO... Saint Bobby only has a couple of seasons left, if that.

ddthetide 12-09-2006 01:52 PM

jimbo fisher was offered the OC job at fsu already. he's playing the waiting game to see how things fall out. he wanted to go home to wv IF CRR took the Bama job.

Cajungator26 12-09-2006 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danzig188
oops. put florida, it was miami that was rumored to be interested. didn't see anything about bama wanting him.

Spurrier went to Bama to look into the job, and when he came back, SC gave him a raise and a contract extension through 2012. Before they hired Meyer a couple of years ago, Spurrier looked into coming back to Florida. He is a very proud man and didn't like the fact that he was told he would have to interview for the job just like everyone else. He knew that he would have a difficult time living up to Florida's expectations since he had already taken them to the top, so he went to a team where he could try and do the same thing that he had done for Florida.

Cajungator26 12-09-2006 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ddthetide
jimbo fisher was offered the OC job at fsu already. he's playing the waiting game to see how things fall out. he wanted to go home to wv IF CRR took the Bama job.

I don't care for Jimbo Fisher... he's got a tie in with the Bowdens though, so perhaps he'll end up with FSU for sure. If so, they can have him! :p

ddthetide 12-09-2006 01:56 PM

i'll ask you guys this question.
would rather coach in the big east and win 8-9-10 games a year and an automatic BCS bowl bid OR have to coach a SEC street fight each week? IF you can win 10-11 games you play for the NC.

BellamyRd. 12-09-2006 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ddthetide
i'll ask you guys this question.
would rather coach in the big east and win 8-9-10 games a year and an automatic BCS bowl bid OR have to coach a SEC street fight each week? IF you can win 10-11 games you play for the NC.

Coach Rod had the chance to play for a BCS game
but lost on his HOME TURF to South Florida
let me repeat South Florida!
that's really putting WV in contetion, isn't there Zigo?

Danzig 12-09-2006 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cajungator26
Spurrier went to Bama to look into the job, and when he came back, SC gave him a raise and a contract extension through 2012. Before they hired Meyer a couple of years ago, Spurrier looked into coming back to Florida. He is a very proud man and didn't like the fact that he was told he would have to interview for the job just like everyone else. He knew that he would have a difficult time living up to Florida's expectations since he had already taken them to the top, so he went to a team where he could try and do the same thing that he had done for Florida.

i know spurrier and saban were on 'bama's wish list, but both seemed to shoot down any thoughts about going there, or anywhere, pretty quickly.

timmgirvan 12-09-2006 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oracle80
Yeah ok sure, and I've been asked by President Bush to interview to be the new terror czar.

God! there's hope for us,yet!:D

Kasept 12-09-2006 02:28 PM

Coach is benched 48 hours.. Can come back Monday calm and refreshed and talk to others here like they're human beings...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:31 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.