Derby Trail Forums

Derby Trail Forums (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Paddock (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Inspirational and depressing at the same time (http://www.derbytrail.com/forums/showthread.php?t=22445)

SniperSB23 05-14-2008 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by justindew
...and when is the last time the 5th place finisher in the BC Classic earned a 108?

2004, actually it was a 109 then.

justindew 05-14-2008 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
2004, actually it was a 109 then.

I think that was Azeri. She got a 109? Really? Wow.

SniperSB23 05-14-2008 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by justindew
I think that was Azeri. She got a 109? Really? Wow.

Lifetime she had a 112, a 111, two 110s, and four 109s. Now we get excited when a mare runs a 105.

justindew 05-14-2008 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SniperSB23
Lifetime she had a 112, a 111, two 110s, and four 109s. Now we get excited when a mare runs a 105.

Oh, I wasn't surprised she ran a 109, I was surprised she ran a 109 in the BC Calssic.

Cannon Shell 05-14-2008 06:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cardus
34-1, right? Of the other two, Gentlemen was the first to give way, and was well, well beaten that day. I don't recall the winner's margin, but it was a few lengths at least.

What a dank day at Belmont.

Yes he was. Gentleman was lame in the test barn afterwards. I think Siphon was in there too? Skip Away didnt look too good in the paddock before the race either.

Cannon Shell 05-14-2008 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by parsixfarms
I agree that some were not fashionably bred, but compared to the others listed above, Behrens (Pleasant Colony), Will's Way (Easy Goer) and Captain Bodgit (Saint Ballado) certainly fit the bill. Starting out, they were certainly no less fashionably bred than horses like Indian Charlie (In Excess), Valid Expectations (Valid Appeal), Northern Afleet (Afleet), and Smoke Glacken (Two Punch).

Horses like Distorted Humor, Arch, and Elusive Quality all began their careers at stud fees in the $10,000 range, so it's not like they were getting bred to top mares when they started out. They just outperformed their more recognizable (from a racing perspective) contemporaries in the breeding shed and, as a result, are now getting the top mares that they earned the hard way.

Finally, the Thoroughbred Times Stallion Directory lists Captain Bodgit as standing in Canada.

Northern Afleet should not be included with IC, VE, or SG. Outside of Afleet Alex he has no top class runners. He ranked in the 60's on last years sire list. he is fair at best as a sire

Danzig 05-14-2008 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cardus
All mares are earned that way, I guess.


well, yeah, that's true...

RolloTomasi 05-14-2008 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cardus
34-1, right? Of the other two, Gentlemen was the first to give way, and was well, well beaten that day. I don't recall the winner's margin, but it was a few lengths at least.

What a dank day at Belmont.

Actually, it was the other way around. Gentlemen, who gave Skip Away a brief scare in the Woodward, finally put that one away in early stretch of the JCGC, only to get run down by Wagon Limit.

Gentlemen was still 5 lengths in front of Skip Away at the wire.

prudery 05-14-2008 08:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedigree Ann
None of these top runners was fashionably-bred; in fact, they were all considered a bit 'down-market' in their breeding and were treated accordingly by the top tier breeders. They got the mares who were out of the half-sisters to the good runners instead of the half-sisters themselves, that sort of thing. Captain Bodgit died young, too.

Actually, Ann, it was Saint Ballado-- the Captain's SIRE that died young ....

philcski 05-14-2008 09:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedigree Ann
None of these top runners was fashionably-bred; in fact, they were all considered a bit 'down-market' in their breeding and were treated accordingly by the top tier breeders. They got the mares who were out of the half-sisters to the good runners instead of the half-sisters themselves, that sort of thing. Captain Bodgit died young, too.

The Captain is alive and kicking.

parsixfarms 05-15-2008 01:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
Northern Afleet should not be included with IC, VE, or SG. Outside of Afleet Alex he has no top class runners. He ranked in the 60's on last years sire list. he is fair at best as a sire

You missed the point. I was comparing Skip Away, Behrens, Silver Charm and company to other horses that began their stud careers in 1998 and 1999. Considering the relatively low quality mares that Northern Afleet saw in Florida when he first started (I believe he was standing for as low as $5,000), he has been an "overachiever" as a sire. He has consistently "moved up" his mares (AEI of 1.63 v. CI of 1.43), so it will be interesting to see what he does with the better opportunities afforded him recently; his first KY-conceived crop of horses (on a $12,500 stud fee) hit the ground this year.

Travis Stone 05-15-2008 07:48 AM

I believe it was Formal Gold and Will's Way who battled down the stretch in the Whitney? That was the summer of great finishes at Saratoga.

Cannon Shell 05-15-2008 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by parsixfarms
You missed the point. I was comparing Skip Away, Behrens, Silver Charm and company to other horses that began their stud careers in 1998 and 1999. Considering the relatively low quality mares that Northern Afleet saw in Florida when he first started (I believe he was standing for as low as $5,000), he has been an "overachiever" as a sire. He has consistently "moved up" his mares (AEI of 1.63 v. CI of 1.43), so it will be interesting to see what he does with the better opportunities afforded him recently; his first KY-conceived crop of horses (on a $12,500 stud fee) hit the ground this year.

He is a weak sire. His number of stakes winners for a 15 year old stallion with 7 crops of racing age is 16 which is not good. He has had one horse of note in 7 crops. His 1st and 3rd leading money winners are out of the same mare(who needs to get a lot of the credit). His AEI and CI's are skewed by the fact he stood in FL where many mares havent earned a lot of money, especially in relation to slot fueled purses elsewhere, but are still solid producers. I dont think he got much for mares in KY except the older or cheaper ones. Unfortunately for me I have 3 coming next year for a client unless a miracle happens and he can sell them. I guess I may be biased but after 7 crops I would like to see a whole lot more. It wasnt like he was standing in Wyoming.

I know Skip Away probably had better mares to start out but his numbers are better than NA, and personally I think SC is a better sire also. Beherns, notsomuch

freddymo 05-15-2008 10:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by justindew
I found this over at DRF.com. I think this horse got robbed of Horse of the Year in 1997. He faced Skip Away six times, and beat him in four of those races.

112 debut Beyer? Will we ever see that again? And he raced nine times in 1997, racing at least once a month from February through September.

One of my favorites of all time.

http://community.drf.com/formblog/files/formal_gold.pdf

A colt who actually went thru his conditions how novel a thought

freddymo 05-15-2008 10:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
He is a weak sire. His number of stakes winners for a 15 year old stallion with 7 crops of racing age is 16 which is not good. He has had one horse of note in 7 crops. His 1st and 3rd leading money winners are out of the same mare(who needs to get a lot of the credit). His AEI and CI's are skewed by the fact he stood in FL where many mares havent earned a lot of money, especially in relation to slot fueled purses elsewhere, but are still solid producers. I dont think he got much for mares in KY except the older or cheaper ones. Unfortunately for me I have 3 coming next year for a client unless a miracle happens and he can sell them. I guess I may be biased but after 7 crops I would like to see a whole lot more. It wasnt like he was standing in Wyoming.

I know Skip Away probably had better mares to start out but his numbers are better than NA, and personally I think SC is a better sire also. Beherns, notsomuch

Chuck go look at the book NA was bred to like 6 years ago..I swear some of them weren't TB's.. I reviewed his entire book once Afleet Alex started to emerge and I didn't see a single quality mare out of the 40 to 50 he had been bred to.. I think you have to wait and see what happens now that he has some sponsorship.

parsixfarms 05-15-2008 10:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
I know Skip Away probably had better mares to start out but his numbers are better than NA

I guess we can agree to disagree on Northern Afleet as a sire. To my way of thinking, if he's on the top 100 sire list given the opportunities that he's had, I have a hard time calling him "weak."

As for Skip Away, he's never had a horse of significance, his AEI (1.32) is below his CI (1.43), and his yearlings and 2YOs sell for next to nothing, so I fail to see how "his numbers are better than" Northern Afleet.

Cannon Shell 05-15-2008 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by parsixfarms
I guess we can agree to disagree on Northern Afleet as a sire. To my way of thinking, if he's on the top 100 sire list given the opportunities that he's had, I have a hard time calling him "weak."

As for Skip Away, he's never had a horse of significance, his AEI (1.32) is below his CI (1.43), and his yearlings and 2YOs sell for next to nothing, so I fail to see how "his numbers are better than" Northern Afleet.

take away AA and what do you have? He is a one horse wonder. 571 foals and 16 stakes winners and 13 stakes place horses. that is a miserable number. This is after 7 crops. That is very weak. We arent talking graded stakes horses, just stakes horses. Including all those bs calder stakes. If not for the mother of AA and UM he would have virtually no top flight horses. He is not a Bad sire but he is not very good yet and projecting success based on getting better mares is dangerous.

SA has had more graded stakes winners, stakes winners and stakes placed horses than NA and the last few years he has had foal crops of 50 or less. he aint good but it is hard to make a case that NA is better.

Maybe I am being elitist but to my thinking you could breed to billy goats and be on the top 100 sire list

Cannon Shell 05-15-2008 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freddymo
Chuck go look at the book NA was bred to like 6 years ago..I swear some of them weren't TB's.. I reviewed his entire book once Afleet Alex started to emerge and I didn't see a single quality mare out of the 40 to 50 he had been bred to.. I think you have to wait and see what happens now that he has some sponsorship.

16 stakes winners out of 571 foals is really weak. He should be a $4000 regional sire.

slotdirt 05-15-2008 02:38 PM

Where are we getting this 571 foal number? According to the Stallion Register, Northern Afleet has sired 348 horses of racing age, 244 runners, 70 percent winners, and 14 stakes winners. Skip Away's numbers are pretty similar. Considering - again - the mares one probably got versus the other, I'd suggest Northern Afleet has done pretty darn well for himself.

This is a great discussion though as both are sixth-crop sires and it makes for a really good comparison.

Cannon Shell 05-15-2008 02:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slotdirt
Where are we getting this 571 foal number? According to the Stallion Register, Northern Afleet has sired 348 horses of racing age, 244 runners, 70 percent winners, and 14 stakes winners. Skip Away's numbers are pretty similar. Considering - again - the mares one probably got versus the other, I'd suggest Northern Afleet has done pretty darn well for himself.

This is a great discussion though as both are sixth-crop sires and it makes for a really good comparison.

as of 5/12/08 from equineline

Statistical summary for the registered progeny of Northern Afleet:

8 crops
571 foals
7 crops of racing age
493 foals of racing age
131 current 2 year old foals
78 yearlings
0 weanlings

In North America / USA, Australia, Canada, England, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy,
Japan, UAE, and all other available foreign data:

1 champions
3 graded stakes winners
16 stakes winners
13 stakes placers



I suppose that you could say from 493 potential starters

slotdirt 05-15-2008 02:59 PM

Fair enough.

philcski 05-15-2008 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannon Shell
as of 5/12/08 from equineline

Statistical summary for the registered progeny of Northern Afleet:

8 crops
571 foals
7 crops of racing age
493 foals of racing age
131 current 2 year old foals
78 yearlings
0 weanlings

In North America / USA, Australia, Canada, England, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy,
Japan, UAE, and all other available foreign data:

1 champions
3 graded stakes winners
16 stakes winners
13 stakes placers



I suppose that you could say from 493 potential starters

He's only had 3 graded stakes winners?!?

parsixfarms 05-15-2008 03:07 PM

Skip Away has one more graded stakes winner (4), and only three more stakes winners despite getting better mares at the start of his career.

Based on the attention brought from Afleet Alex (and a few others such as G P Fleet, Saint Afleet, and all those Wynn horses), Northern Afleet has received the chance (getting $10,000 to $20,000 mares in KY) over the past few years that Skip Away got immediately when he retired from the track. If you're right, he'll become the new Our Emblem. Time will tell.

Cannon Shell 05-15-2008 08:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by parsixfarms
Skip Away has one more graded stakes winner (4), and only three more stakes winners despite getting better mares at the start of his career.

Based on the attention brought from Afleet Alex (and a few others such as G P Fleet, Saint Afleet, and all those Wynn horses), Northern Afleet has received the chance (getting $10,000 to $20,000 mares in KY) over the past few years that Skip Away got immediately when he retired from the track. If you're right, he'll become the new Our Emblem. Time will tell.

Being marginally better than Skip Away (maybe) is not exactly a ringing endorsement. How many times have you seen a cheap mare bred to bad sires who produces a couple of stakes horses suddenly gets a huge upgrade in stallions and doesnt do anything?

You got a bunch of NA's?

Cannon Shell 05-15-2008 08:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by philcski
He's only had 3 graded stakes winners?!?

2 from the same mare. he appears to be a good cross with hawkster mares or at least one


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:48 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.