Yeah, I was referring to Brian's comments...and I'm not really insulted just joking with him! But I am serious about my evaluation that she's 7th right now...she could with a good performance next week (if she's still there) become one of the top 12.

IDOL
 

Wow, Cant Picture Byk Watching Idol? Anyway, The Black Girls Are Way Above The Rest And Barba Is A Terrible Singer Who Should Be A Model. That One Scat Girl Has A Clown Face, And The Chub From Chicago Wont Make It Either. Not Much Of A Group This Year So Far!

last night was the first we watched since the first 2 weeks. Lakisha and Melinda are so FAR ahead of the reat it's not close. Jordin and Sabrina are a tie for 3rd and the rest are behind them. Leslie, that sings the jazz or scat is good at that, she's different from the rest. JMO.

Seacrest is the biggest no-talent backstabber going,imho!

K, here is my take on his "that would suck comment." I think you guys got it all wrong.....we had the show dvr'd and while we got the that would suck comment, I never heard the other comment....As far as Seacrest's comment, I believe that is strictly related to the fact that he himself gave out wrong #'s in a previous season....Remember, they screwed up and no one was voted off that particular week. I don't think it had anything to do with Barba. In fact I thought they were extremely cautious not to even get near the issue.

After thinking about it more today, I think you may be right in that it wasn't an Antonella joke. It may have just been a reference to a wrong number being displayed.